Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 October 2005

IPod 2, no revolution, just another form of catch up TV

Of course the new iPod will sell, but Faultline is firmly of the belief that when Apple’s Steve Jobs says something, he means it, and he pointed out that the device that he launched last week is an experiment. OK, to some extent it’s an experiment that cannot fail, because the device is really just an iPod, with a nice screen that doesn’t come with a price premium.

In effect, in future, if consumers want an iPod, they might as well buy the video iPod.

But it has to be understood, that the thought and precision and aggressive negotiation that Jobs put into the original iTunes and its pricing, is missing here and analysts should think more of this device launch, with the addition of a shiny new screen, as defensive rather than offensive.

In Faultline’s view, Apple had a shot at tying up the video market in one go in the same way that it tied up music, and it has missed its chance. As we say the device will sell, some video will sell, but the real battles in portable video lay ahead for the video iPod, not behind it.

When iTunes was first launched all the content was lined up in advance and the record labels signed up on Jobs’ terms because they feared rampant piracy. At the time Apple and Jobs played the role of savior.

Whereas for the video iPod launch, if it had not been that Jobs’ other company Pixar, having Disney over a barrel, the launch would have been a video iPod with precious little video.

Disney has been worried for over a year at the prospect of ending its relationship with Pixar which had contributed a huge amount of Disney’s total annual profit. If it has not been for this it is hard to see why new Disney CEO Bob Iger, would have considered opening up hot weekly shows like ‘Lost’ and ‘Desperate Housewives.’

The problem here is that shows like these are created and usually offered as exclusives. Both the networks that buy them and the content companies that make them want to squeeze more money out of these shows. They are expensive to make, and for the content companies the revenues of the successful shows need to make up for all the losses made on less successful shows, and so a hit is charged out at high rates.

The price has to be met by the broadcast networks, and they are happy to do anything that will offset this cost.

What happens is that both sides of the operation, Disney and its customers, are both dreaming up initiatives to take out some of the pain of high costs. The networks want to put it on the internet for a few days after the episodes are shown, the content companies want to offer it for the iPod as soon as they are shown. Affiliates that carry the networks just want the shows to stay exclusive to them to maximize their revenue potential.

Since both sides of the equation have to give their permission to have their exclusive deal made slightly less exclusive, then it is safe to assume that both sides of the equation are getting some of the money. In this case because both sides are owned by Disney that doesn’t matter.

Disney and other content companies that have put episodes on the internet lately, have to ensure that these early copies, do not cut into the DVD revenues that these programs can attract once the series has been broadcast.

All this falls into the same category as TiVo, in that it is a form of what we call catch up TV. In a fast moving, uncompromisingly and disparate modern world, hardly anyone can arrange to be in one place at the same time every week to watch a major series. They need a way of recording it, or viewing it in alternative format, and if we cluster all of that as ‘catch up TV,’ then we can see that web portals, TiVo, VHS recorders and the video iPod, are all just versions of the same thing. Similarly innovations such as PocketDish that EchoStar’s Dish network launched last week, whereby broadcast TV can be recorded, and watched on the go, is another such innovation.

Each of these have two ways of getting to a home, over a best effort internet line or recorded from a broadcast. Both approaches need a digital rights management system, to ensure that these same broadcasts are not then shared over the internet.

But equally these formats need to be either temporary in nature, so that when the full series comes out on DVD, it still has some value. Without the follow on DVD revenue, many of the current top US TV series would no longer be affordable.

But even if all that works out, there is an inevitable conflict built into catch up TV, and there is only an uneasy truce between companies that ‘make’ TV programming and those that broadcast it. And in the end this truce is likely to end up being broken by the ‘lure’ of catch up TV.

One of the first things that companies were happy to share with internet portals were reality TV programs. This is because these became popular not because the public like them, but because these are programs that the broadcaster can easily and cheaply make themselves.

This cuts out the reliance on external content companies, and although some of the media conglomerates such as Disney, Viacom and Fox make programs as well as owning a broadcast network, each individual part of these empires want to be inherently more profitable than their siblings.

Reality TV was a godsend to broadcasters, because they could be less reliant on content businesses and yet not have terrible viewing figures (although most reality TV tails off in viewing figures rather rapidly compared to top seasonal favorites like ‘Lost’).

But reality TV perfectly illustrates the way the two types of organizations pull in different directions. So in the iPod deal we have the ABC broadcast network offering the exclusive Lost programming to Apple, partially because its parent, Disney, wants to get hold of Pixar films. That convoluted logic is not going to reappear between many content companies and their customers, which begs the question, where will Apple find more content from for its video iPod.

Another issue is that ad free replays of these popular shows are currently considered to add to their momentum and viewing figures. The iPod or Google versions (as in Everybody Hates Chris) mean that less people drop out along the journey, especially of something like ’24.’ It may be a different matter when it begins to be a source of people no longer viewing advertisements because a large percentage of them begin watching over the internet or on an iPod.

Serialized shows never go down well as repeats and there is a mentality around them that says that first time around the audience must be maximized.

But all of this can be characterized as catch up TV. Soon, the extra revenues, whether they come from Google or Yahoo, or Apple or even from download businesses such as Movielink and CinemaNow or from innovators like Akimbo, or from FIOS TV at Verizon or from IPTV services from SBC Communications, will become embedded in the exploitation cycle of a piece of content.

Effectively if a serialized content company doesn’t have a catch up TV strategy, they’re toast.

So we can expect legal contracts for all new TV series to go into a rapid round of renegotiation, with generalized catch up rights options put into all programming and a clear delineation on revenues between the content company and the broadcaster that has an exclusive on showing that content.

Catch up revenues will only include either iPod or other downloaded portable player options or internet portal options or both and are likely to be for limited time periods so that there will be little or no DVD sales dilution.

So the consumer is likely to have a choice of where he or she wants to watch the missing episode on a PC, TV or iPod or other portable player. In iTunes, Apple didn’t have an exclusive on online music, but it has a huge market lead in offering its services. In video it doesn’t.

Right now where would you watch your missed episode of ‘Lost?’ On an iPod, where you have to pay for it, on a TiVo, VHS or DVD recorder, or on a PC linked to a popular portal? where you don’t have to pay for it? I know my answer.

In the end catch up TV alone will not turn the video iPod into a second wave iPod success of the magnitude of iTunes, and Steve Jobs needs to be on the road tying down content deals ahead of Google, and others in order to make iTunes the place to go for video. Currently iTunes is the place to go for music videos, because there are 2,000 of them up there, but those aside you can download and watch every other video that’s available for a video iPod in a single day.

If all the networks called Steve Jobs the day after the video iPod launch and said, ‘Hey can we do that with our show,’ then perhaps Apple still has a chance to turn this launch into a serious money earner.

Otherwise this is very much ‘just another iPod’ a bit like the Photo iPod and the Shuffle, rather than a new wave or revolution in its own right. That doesn’t mean that it won’t sell at all, but it certainly won’t cause the momentum that the iTunes launch created, just continue it.

One thing that it may lead to is a place to keep treasured ‘unprotected’ video. So that’s either DVD originated films, personal copies made from TV, a pirated collection or just home movies. How long before showing a static photo from a wallet is replaced by showing a video of little Johnny on a wafer thin iPod, and it comes with all the accessories to achieve this.

It makes far more sense for an adult to carry around an iPod to show these things off, rather than a Sony PSP, regardless of the price differential in Sony’s favor, because the iPod looks serious. We would expect Sony to eventually come out with versions of the PSP that don’t look so obviously like a console controller, so that it can pick up on the ‘serious’ adult market that rarely play games.

But already the hysteria of the launch and the jealously over the new iPod deal has made it into news coverage. Five unions representing actors, writers and directors issued a call for talks to make sure their members get a cut of revenue generated by the sale of TV shows on Apple’s iTunes software. Funnily enough this thorny problem has never come up with other ‘personal’ copies of content, created by DVD recorders, and the like, and even though the Sony PSP allows video content to be copied straight from a TV to a Memory Pro stick, to play on the PSP. That’s because most of these ‘personal’ copies are free.

It’s not exactly difficult to lump all these revenues with DVD sales or internet sales, but the Unions felt the need to make public statements because they were worried about missing out on the iPod effect and because broadcast delivery yields a higher percentage of revenue to actors and writers than DVD sales.

Given what Steve Jobs always said in the past that he didn’t think people would watch video on a small screen, it comes as no surprise that at the same time as the video iPod (or to give it its correct name iPod 2) starting at $1,299, Apple also covered the Microsoft Media Center and Intel Viiv PC, offering an iMac G5 with its own remote control and a special interface for viewing from up to 30 feet away.

That interface is called Front Row and it sits on a new, thinner G5 which also supports video conferencing out of the box and comes free with the Photo Booth application.

Apple boasted that its remote control has only six buttons, compared to remote controls for Microsoft’s Media Center which it says usually have over 40 buttons.

The new iMac G5 comes in a 17-inch and a 20-inch model, with a SuperDrive for burning professional-quality DVDs, five USB ports and two FireWire ports.

So if the iPod video is a flop, at least Apple customers will have something to watch their downloaded copies of Disney and Pixar programs on.