The share price of DirecTV has been pretty static since News Corp acquired 34% of the company and took management control almost three years ago. If anything it has slid by about 15% over that period, and is viewed as a declining stock.
The New York Times this week asked the question of whether or not the largest US satellite TV company in the US (if not the world) wouldn’t be well advised to give money back to the shareholders as one of its most effective ways of spending money, rather than continue to use it to fight the cable and RBOCs TV efforts.
The NY Times has completely misread both the situation and the mood of News Corp and its illustrious CEO, Rupert Murdoch.
Murdoch is not about short term vision, nor is he about rewarding shareholders with cash handouts. That’s not to say that he won’t buy back some shares in DirecTV in the near future, that’s just good practice and counter-balances the effect of issuing stock options. Effectively News Corp would end up owning a greater percentage of the company and have more control and beneficial ownership. In the end we are sure that Murdoch would like to see DirecTV 100% owned by News Corp.
But he did not fatten up PanAmSat with distribution contracts and then sell it off for over $4 billion just to give that money away to some hungry shareholders. To understand how Murdoch thinks about long term domination of markets you must think unconventionally. As a financier he is bold, ruthless and a stickler for detail.
So what does Faultline think he could or should do, and what do we predict he will do with his prize US possession.
The big issue for anyone in control of DirecTV, and in this includes CEO Chase Carey, a long term News Corp lieutenant that has worked with Murdoch for the past 20 years, is churn.
If customers desert the DirecTV service faster than new customers arrive, then the company is undone. That’s why the focus from day one at DirecTV was to reduce churn. But it hasn’t worked.
While the number of people canceling DirecTV service has remained constant at between 1.5% and 1.6% of its total customer base per month, this has come at a time when the cable industry at large has an estimate churn of around 2.5%. This translates to an 18% annual churn for DirecTV and a 30% churn for cable companies.
So while Comcast hasn’t added a single customer since it took over AT&T Broadband at around the same time that News Corp was getting its hands on DirecTV, and is static at roughly 21 million customers, DirecTV has added some 2.7 million customers to take subscribers to 14.7 million since Murdoch took over. His promise at the time was to increase subs by 3 million and he is probably one quarter away from achieving this.
But it is a painful process. Two quarters ago DirecTV added 1 million new subscribers and lost 775,000 existing customers to net out growth at 225,000 subs. This last quarter it netted the same with far lower figures more like 700,000 additions, 475,000 losses for the same net gain. It is three steps forwards and two backwards, and both Carey and Murdoch must be sick of it, spending a small fortune to acquire around 225,000 new subs net each quarter. Quite clearly this is controlled and some of the losses are late payers and the non-acceptance of poor credit risks, making the DirecTV cash flow more concrete. But still that churn could come down.
So what can they do about it?
Well the companies that are supposedly a threat are those which either already offer, or plan to offer, a triple play. Triple play reduces churn, some say to as little as 0.7% a month, or just over 8% per annum. This is considered more or less the lowest rate achievable. If it achieved that, it would be worth 10% of its customer base a year, the equivalent in sustained revenues of $1.2 billion a year, which would be all free cash flow (assuming monthly ARPU is $68 per customer).
This comes about because it is very difficult to change phone supplier, internet supplier and TV supplier in one go, and consumers won’t consider it unless they move home, hit financial difficulties or die.
The other threat comes from Microsoft IPTV, which is pitched at being better TV, a weapon in the hands of the US RBOCs, which could over the next few years, begin to unseat both satellite and cable and drive up their churn.
So for DirecTV to get to that magic 8% churn rate (12% would do), the operation has to both offer a full triple play and it must also offer ‘better’ TV, like the Microsoft system, inside two years.
The latter of these is perhaps easier than the first. Microsoft will eventually empower the RBOCs with four key features, fast channel change, a mosaic interface for channel hopping and multiple screen in screen features, DRM that means the content can be safely copied to portable players and High Definition viewing.
DirecTV has already said that it has purchased the satellite capacity to launch 1,500 HDTV channels. This is its great defense against ‘better’ TV. Today there is nothing like enough content to fill these channels, or is there? Special adaptations to its programming (such as sports programming) could show three or more pictures at once on a screen. For baseball Microsoft indicates that this might be the pitcher, the whole field and the hitter in three separate images, separately recorded and zooming independently of each other.
This can be constructed in two clear ways. Either multiple streams are decoded at the set top and merged on the fly using multiple tuners (expensive and complex) or two and three ‘picture in picture’ combinations can be created at the head end and sent as completed screens and customers can flip between combo channels.
One channel may feature the three camera views edited, one at a time, another few may have any combination of two cameras and one may combine all three into one screen. If this is done in High Definition then new programming options might absorb 1,500 video streams quite rapidly. Offering lots of pay per view and Near Video on Demand services will also give DirecTV a defense against real VoD.
The mosaic of 20 or so miniaturized low definition live video channels can be created the same way, to offer a way to see what’s on all of the channels. Also channel change speed on satellite can be marginally improved at the set top, and that’s more or less covered the ‘better’ TV phenomena. It will cost a lot, but the commitment has already been put in place with the extra satellite power and the new set top DVR design coming under DirecTV’s control by shifting to a new NDS designed device.
DRM for DirecTV is also easy and its Israel and UK based NDS conditional access subsidiary has been working on the Secure Video Processor Alliance, a way to copy programming to portable devices.
Now how about that triple play? Well one of the things that DirecTV doesn’t have to deliver over an internet line is video. That means that unlike the RBOCs and the Cable TV operators, it only has to find a way of delivering two to three concurrent voice streams per home, plus look after one or two sessions of html internet delivery. This can all be done on 500 Kbps at the low end, but certainly on 1.5 Mbps. If it was able to find a broadband route to the home of perhaps 3 Mbps, then it might even add genuine VoD alongside its other services, or simple file downloading of video files.
In the UK, where News Corp uses BSkyB as an experimental dry run, the company is now delivering file downloads of programming to hold and play. These are only released to existing customers of its high end premium film services. It is effectively offering a kind of ‘Free’ Akimbo service (download VoD) to its top subscribers for films that play on the PC or the TV.
The company this week has also stated that it will raise $1.2 billion in a bond issue to buy a broadband company in the UK, and most reports are suggesting that this will be one of the oldest local loop unbundlers in the UK, Easynet. This won’t take a quarter of that money, so it may well buy more than one.
Unbundling the local loop in the UK is the same as being a CLEC in the US, and it has become a stronger activity as the regulator Offcom has clarified and tightened connection rules that the incumbent British Telecom, must operate under. Unbundlers can buy their own DSLAMs and attach them to the BT Phone Exchanges and take access traffic from the last mile onto their own networks
The opposite has happened in the US. Instead of increased and stricter regulation, the RBOCs have used the courts to shake off FCC imposed CLEC pricing and are returning to market bargaining for unbundled attachment. That means that DirecTV cannot reasonably copy its UK strategy directly because it would put itself in the hands of the RBOCs on pricing of the unbundled connection and that could be potential suicide. But it can do something analogous.
Both wireless broadband and broadband over powerline bypass the RBOC networks, and that’s where DirecTV must acquire its return path. All of the service experiments in the UK can be offered in the US, but the path mustn’t travel via the incumbent Telco, so this dictates wireless or powerline.
As long as the return path is a set of uniform services that can be centrally advertised, then it doesn’t matter if in one state they are supplied by powerline and in another by a wireless partner like Clearwire, as long as they offer the same speeds and same prices and these are competitive with broadband from cable and from the RBOCs.
Certainly Murdoch has stood up and said that he plans to buy a wireless broadband operator and it was well publicized that he attempted to talk to Skype before it was purchased by Ebay.
That supports all the logic we have given above, that a return path of 3 Mbps per home delivered by either Wireless Broadband or perhaps powerline or a combination of both, plus a VoIP service that can scale to be US wide, are far more elegant investments to cure all the ills at DirecTV more easily and effectively than giving shareholders back funds through dividends or share buy backs.
DirecTV could spend up to $2.5 billion of its cash on acquiring these assets and more by issuing new shares if need be, and yet with $330 million in positive operating cashflow during the past quarter, plus the $1.2 billion we calculate that it would improve cashflow by, would mean that the money would be back in the coffers a year after making such a bold strategy work.
And if DirecTV is careful of the way it plays this particular return path card, it could well find itself within two years either owning or partnering with a wireless business that can either offer wi-fi voice or a full cellular voice service, to add to the triple play.
To simply declare a strategy this inventive would surely put the DirecTV share price back in credit, to successfully execute on it would potentially double the value of the company.