As predicted by Faultline two weeks ago, another of the last two remaining studios holding out in favor of the HD DVD standard, has caved in and said it will offer both Blu-ray disks and HD-DVD.
This time it’s Warner Brothers that has broken its earlier HD DVD stance, two weeks back it was Paramount. The last HD DVD only studio is Universal, although this is unlikely to last more than a few weeks. And Warner Brothers appears to be saying that it will no longer use HD DVD. Paramount at least kept its options open to use both.
Paramount’s statement that it will offer both formats, was a way of saving face for picking the wrong format, but it is likely that it won’t have the opportunity to offer both, given that now the studios are faltering, it is possible the HD DVD format may never see the light of day.
For two years now we have been saying that the support from Blu-ray was too strong for it to lose the next generation DVD wars, and it is now on the brink of winning outright.
The Warner Brothers move is yet another body blow to the DVD Forum which pushed the HD DVD standard. Intel and Microsoft have only just come out in support of the HD DVD format in a cynical attempt to placate its proposers, Toshiba and NEC. Microsoft has been partnering with Toshiba on other format issues and in May Microsoft and Toshiba cut a wide ranging patent swap, which appeared to be targeted at HDTV technology.
The PC community rounded on Microsoft and Intel for lending their support to the standard at the last minute in an attempt to keep it alive.
Blu-ray is now backed by Sony, Philips, Samsung, Panasonic, Pioneer, Hitachi, Thomson, LG Electronics, Mitsubishi, Sharp, TDK, JVC and Apple and studios Sony, MGM, Fox, Lion’s Gate and Disney, while PC and workstation makers Dell, Hewlett Packard, Sun Microsystems and Texas Instruments also back Blu-ray.
However this week Hewlett-Packard went public on a number of requests to the Blu-ray consortium asking it to add two technologies that it sees as key to the format.
The company has formally appealed to the Blu-ray Disc Association (BDA) to include mandatory Managed Copy and iHD as part of its format specification. Both technologies are currently supported in the competing HD-DVD format.
As we understand it Blu-ray has always intended to support Managed Copy as this was part of a separate specification, the AACS specification that both Blu-ray and HD-DVD promised to adhere to. Managed Copy allows consumers to make legitimate copies of their HD movies and move these copies across home networks. However it appears that the particular way that Blu-ray has implemented Managed Copy means that studios can choose to turn off the feature in Blu-ray versions which might mean that users could be prevented from making their own personal copies of content.
iHD is a Microsoft alternative to some Hewlett-Packard Java based technology which is designed to offer interactive features on Blu-Ray DVDs. The fact that HP, the proposer of the Java code, is the one asking for it to be replaced by Microsoft code, carries quite a bit of weight.
Microsoft plans to implement iHD in Windows Vista.
Microsoft isn’t in too strong a position here, except that it appears to have leverage over HP. Sony now has the studios on its side, even the studio closest to Microsoft, in Warner Brothers. But Sony will not want to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by refusing to go along with anything it considers just a minor alteration, and it will really be the studios that decide these final few steps on the integration of the two formats.