A group of wireless heavyweights, most themselves holding significant patent portfolios, has lodged a complaint with the European Commission, claiming Qualcomm is violating antitrust laws and keeping competitors from entering the 3G chip market in Europe through its business practices. The complaint accuses Qualcomm of refusing to license essential patents to potential chipset competitors on fair terms, while offering lower royalty rates to handset customers that agree to exclusively purchase chipsets from Qualcomm.
Qualcomm immediately responded publicly to the complaint saying that it had no merit.
The companies also charge Qualcomm with charging excessive and disproportionate royalties for essential W-CDMA patents. The companies involved in the complaint also assert Qualcomm’s “anticompetitive behavior has harmful effects for the mobile telecommunications sector in Europe as well as elsewhere, because carriers and consumers are facing higher prices and fewer choices.’ The group is led by Broadcom, which has been engaged in a series of tit-for-tat patent lawsuits with its rival most of this year and has also filed antitrust suits in the US that are similar, in essence, to the European complaint. It is joined by Ericsson, NEC, Nokia, Panasonic Mobile Communications and Texas Instruments. Along with Qualcomm, Ericsson and Nokia are the major patent holders in W-CDMA, but have been campaigning ‘ under their own pressures from customers ‘ to limit the total royalties payable on any handset, a view that Qualcomm has not supported. Ericsson mounted the last great challenge to the US vendor’s patent-based control of the CDMA technology from 1997, and the companies’ eventual truce in 2002, which involved Ericsson licensing the CDMA patents but taking Qualcomm’s equipment business off its hands, set the stage for the chipmaker’s dominance of its market in the past years.
However, the stakes rose when a CDMA-based technology, Wideband CDMA, was adopted for the 3G evolution for the GSM world, meaning that Qualcomm controlled fundamental intellectual property in both major platforms. This meant that wireless chipmakers, which had largely resigned themselves after the Ericsson settlement to staying out of the CDMA sector, were faced with the threat that Qualcomm could repeat its success and dominate W-CDMA too. There are strengths and weaknesses to this argument, compared with challenging Qualcomm only in its home territory, where its near-monopoly status is undoubted ‘ companies that have sought to compete in the CDMA chip market have invariably failed, and even the ongoing attempt by Texas Instruments, STMicro and Nokia, the most credible so far, has struggled to make an impact.
However, Qualcomm has an influence on the CDMA2000 and 3GPP2 market that it could not match elsewhere, whatever its patent rights. Some of TI’s stumbles have been blamed on the fact that Qualcomm abandoned the planned EV-DV evolution of CDMA2000, into which TI had ploughed much of its R&D, on the basis of lack of operator demand ‘ but possibly also to wrongfoot the new challenger. In W-CDMA, however, where TI and equipment makers such as Ericsson hold such sway, Qualcomm could not direct the agenda in the same way. Also, Qualcomm can hardly, at this stage, be accused of being a near-monopoly in W-CDMA.
Although it represents a growing percentage of its royalty revenues, it has sold very few chips in the market. Since W-CDMA was adopted as the 3G successor for the GSM community, Qualcomm executives have been touting the figure of 50% market share as their goal, once the sector is fully mature. But most observers believe this to be over optimistic, and 25% to be a more realistic forecast. To date, Qualcomm is still waiting for its first major W-CDMA design win, while its arch-rival Texas Instruments takes a clear market lead, without the aid of such great stocks of IP. It does, however, make more money from W-CDMA licensing. In the last two quarters, almost one-third of Qualcomm’s royalty revenue came from this technology, because ‘ reversing the pattern of the 2G world ‘ handset selling prices are far higher in WCDMA than CDMA2000, and royalties are calculated as a percentage of unit price.
This may anger W-CDMA players that have to pay the fees to Qualcomm, but part of the reason for the price differential is that so many other companies also have patents included in the standard ‘ Nokia, Motorola and Ericsson being the other notable examples. And the fact that the 3GPP selected a CDMA-based technology in full knowledge of Qualcomm’s policies on royalties supports the San Diego company’s claims that its dominance is built on technological superiority rather than sharp practices.
But the timing is significant. The 3G vendors are well aware that the market is changing and that traditional royalty policies are unlikely to hold good. 3G operators and vendors are facing unprecedented threats from alternative technologies, such as WiMAX, that could be used by non-3G carriers to mount competitive services, particularly as part of a fixed-mobile convergence strategy like that of British Telecom. The intellectual property regime that will attach to WiMAX is highly uncertain and one of the key risk factors for the rapid spread of the technology. So far, the only claimed holder of fundamental patents to seek to attract significant licensing revenues, and threaten to sue non-supporters, is Wi-Lan, which, despite a legal battle with Cisco, is likely to be small enough to bring to heel or acquire.
There has been much speculation that Qualcomm, since acquiring a large stock of OFDM-related patents, and particularly those held by Flarion, may have got its hands on intellectual property that would enable it to claim a royalty revenue from WiMAX, even without supporting the technology in products. However, there has been no concrete sign of this so far, and Qualcomm has traditionally sought to integrate product and patent revenue streams, always arguing that the pure intellectual property business model ‘ like that of RIM’s nemesis NTP ‘ is limited and unattractive.
But an assertion of fundamental patent rights in WiMAX, by a company that does not benefit from keeping royalties low in the platform, is the nightmare scenario for those that want to see 802.16 networks spread rapidly, something that requires low cost equipment ‘ preferably virtually royalty-free ‘ and a lack of the confusion and fear that patent lawsuits engender.
The most likely outcome, however, is that the patent holders in WiMAX will donate their technologies for no or very low royalties to the standard in order to speed its adoption and make equipment price competitive with the heavily royalty-burdened 3G. In response, the 3G intellectual property giants have been seeking to reduce that royalty burden to make their own technologies more attractive, a move that has been thwarted by Qualcomm. In the next 12 years, the mobile device industry could spend between $80bn and $100bn in royalties on 3G patents held primarily by Qualcomm, Nokia, Motorola and Ericsson, estimates Informa. Qualcomm has set its royalty rate at between 4.65% and 6%.
From 2002, Nokia has led calls for an industry-wide 5% limit on royalty rates for 3G patents, which Qualcomm dismissed as ‘self-serving’, coming from an equipment maker that pays as much royalty as it collects. “We have licensed more than 50 companies for (use of) WCDMA technology. That list includes Nokia. That demonstrates that the industry thinks our rates are fair and reasonable and not an impediment to the deployment of 3G services,” Qualcomm said at the time, and has stuck to that position. Even at 5%, total royalties would be as much as 20%, and in the current situation, the figure is 25-30% of handset selling price. But the dispute is one factor behind the decision to seek antitrust action at this juncture.
Until recently, Nokia, Ericsson and others could have been vulnerable to some of the same accusations now being hurled at Qualcomm, because of the high rates they charged for their own IP. Now, they can argue that they are seeking to change the system. In the end, though, their new interest in limiting royalties is driven by the fact that they need to sustain the attractiveness of their platforms and drive equipment revenues more than they need to keep patent revenues high. This is especially important as they aim to gain more revenue from developing economies, where handset prices of under $50 are targeted ‘ almost impossible with current royalty burdens.
But Qualcomm’s motivation is the same in this case. It is more reliant on its chip revenues than its patent revenues, and while its intellectual property undoubtedly supports its silicon market share in a far more direct manner than in any other vendor’s model, eventually the need to keep its technology competitive will outweigh the charging of high royalties.
Qualcomm aims to expand out of its traditional bases and gain new customers through its W-CDMA chips, and by offering its OFDM technologies, MediaFLO and Flash- OFDM, to non-CDMA and even fixed line operators. If its products are too encumbered by patent charges, they will be ignored by the equipment makers in these new sectors, which have no legacy reason to support a Qualcomm platform. In this scenario, the company will need to fall back on its other mainstay, technological excellence, something for which it remains renowned. This will become increasingly vital as it faces new challenges even in its core CDMA market.
Korea – whose majors, along with Sprint, were the original backers that enabled CDMA to take off as an alternative to GSM ‘ has grown increasingly restive at the payment of royalties to western suppliers, notably Qualcomm, and, with China, is aggressively developing its own technologies. The most notable example is WiMAX, whose mobile variant will be based on the Wi-Bro platform largely created by Samsung ‘ a fact that has aroused some of the fears over future WiMAX royalties, with doubts over whether that giant will seek to enforce royalty rights at high rates in 802.16e.
More directly problematic for Qualcomm, the Korean operators have devised their own software download platform to replace Brew, and now there is a Korean chipmaker challenging the giant. Eonex is about to release a cellphone with LG, based on its domestically produced CDMA chip and operating software for the Korean market. Chun Sung-hwan, president of Eonex, claimed that the new handset will enable Korean companies to compete more effectively with their global rivals as they develop mobile phone chips and 3G handsets. The Korean manufacturer said it will begin shipping CDMA2000 EV-DO chips in the first half of next year and plans to release a very low cost CDMA2000 1x modem chip targeted at the Indian, south east Asian and Central and South American markets. This should strike more fear into Qualcomm than the protracted and politicized probes of the Department of Justice or European Commission.
Although Eonex will still have to pay royalties to Qualcomm, the creation of an independent and low cost EV-DO platform ‘ the only other current source of EV-DO silicon, although Philips and TI make CDMA chips ‘ is a blow to the far larger revenues Qualcomm gains from its own chipsets. And with Korean government and vendor backing, it could see one of its core markets slipping through its fingers. South Korea’s mobile phone makers currently spend an estimated $2.8bn a year purchasing similar chips from Qualcomm.
Qualcomm is undoubtedly, then, under pressure to an extent that it has not been since it settled with Ericsson. But the company is clever and agile, and though a radical change in its intellectual property strategies, and the way these support its core chip business, may be painful, they will not be fatal to a company that is fully able to compete on the quality of its silicon, the support it provides for its systems, and its understanding of real world operator needs.
Indeed, a rethink of its approaches was almost inevitable once it decided to enter the non-CDMA market, particularly if it seeks to establish significant market share for its OFDM technologies in the markets targeted by the well backed WiMAX. Qualcomm will just be the most dramatic example of a process that most major 3G companies will have to undertake, sacrificing royalty revenues and the influence those bring ‘ out of proportion to the actual cash ‘ for the growth and competitiveness of their products and technology platforms. It will be incumbent on the WiMAX community ‘ and particularly, perhaps, the Korean vendors which are taking such a leading role, and have such a clear interest in balancing the royalty payments they have made to western vendors for so long ‘ to create a new approach to intellectual property that will drive and enhance their platform, not hold it back with levies that will be unsustainable in the increasingly vital developing markets.