Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 November 2005

Vodafone slides past MPEG LA to license key DRM patents

Vodafone has bypassed the MPEG LA group that is licensing the key technologies for OMA Digital Rights Management (DRM), and gone to purchase a license directly from Intertrust. Vodafone has licensed all Intertrust patents for OMA plus it has taken a license to its Marlin DRM technology.

Vodafone is the first operator to break cover and go ahead and license one of the key technology portfolios required for DRM on a phone. Vodafone was one of the early users of the Open Mobile Alliance DRM specification, and currently uses software designed by German specialist CoreMedia to protect content on its successful Live! service.

It is not clear whether or not Vodafone will continue with the CoreMedia product, but in buying a license to Marlin, also OMA compliant, it has the option of using this as a framework for its own DRM. The Marlin DRM can be tuned to the requirements of each operators and come ready made with the Coral Consortium interoperability system. Coral can be used, for instance, to open a gateway between competing DRMs, or to move data from the control of say a conditional access system on a Set Top, to a mobile phone.

The deal has the potential to cause immediate uproar among other members of the GSM Association, which until now had been fighting a rearguard action against the MPEG Licensing Authority, saying that its licensing terms were outrageous. Vodafone will not have to make the terms of its license public and may have negotiated itself a good deal, leaving other operators the problem of accepting the MPEG LA terms that are still on the table, or going their own route and negotiating directly as well, but with perhaps less buying clout than Vodafone

Intertrust Talal Shamoon told Faultline, ‘We have had quite a bit of interest from the mobile community it talking directly to us. I don’t think the GSM Association will be worried that Vodafone has come straight to us. A license from the MPEG LA would only give you certain of the Intertrust patents, and Vodafone wanted more than just those patents. They wanted Marlin as well.’

Initially the MPEG LA, acting for licensees Philips, Sony, Matsushita, Intertrust and ContentGuard asked for $1 per handset plus usage fees from operators. They cut this to $0.65 per handset with a $.025 cap on usage fees per handset per annum, but this was still thought to be far too much and the GSM Association said it would explore alternative technologies.

However the MPEG LA always allows companies to negotiate directly for their patents, and is really only a one stop shop for a cluster of patents that do a single job. Intertrust is top dog in patents for encryption key management, and the other key patent here that needs to be licensed is a Rights Expression Language, and the holder of essential patents in this area is US company Contentguard.

As recently as March the acquisition of Contentguard was completed and it now belongs equally to Microsoft, Thomson and Time Warner with a few shares in the hands of management. However trouble arose in the DRM ranks at Contenguard when the founder and CEO Michael Miron, filed suit against the company’s two majority shareholders, Microsoft and Time Warner, alleging that they “were enriching themselves at the expense of the company and its employee shareholders.”

In other words they were prone to giving the patents away as part of an overall Cellco deal, which of course wouldn’t make Miron very rich, and this suit has not been resolved as far as we know at this time although Miron is no longer with the company and the company has yet to announce his replacement.

Neither Vodafone nor Contentguard could confirm that they have also reached license agreement terms but it seems likely that some deal has been cut, perhaps through Microsoft.

Operators other than Vodafone are not so far down the road in implementing OMA DRM and getting customers to use it in anger and may be able to use different technologies. Sun is one company that has recently made noises about offering a new system for the mobile companies with its DReaM product, but says it won’t be ready for mobile handsets for at least another year.

Many operators are known to be hoping the problem will just go away, and some plan to continue using OMA compliant DRM, and convert to something else, such as DReaM or Marlin, before a license is ever agreed with the MPEG LA.

The GSM Association says it speaks for 1.3 billion mobile customers, through 660 mobile operators, is still believed to be considering up to 14 separate proposals to supply alternative DRM. The Vodafone move will considerably weaken the GSM Association’s position as it cannot promise the lucrative contracts that Vodafone brings, to any new technology offering.

The Vodafone Intertrust license covers Vodafone services that use the OMA DRM. Device makers seeking to sell devices to Vodafone networks will still need to obtain a separate manufacturers’ license from Intertrust, but this is understood to be a cheaper process, since it is the operator that is getting most of the benefit of the DRM because it convinces content owners to release their products onto mobile networks, for which they can then charge a premium.

Given that Philips and Sony own Intertrust, that only leaves Matsushita, and ContentGuard in the MPEG LA patent pool that may still need to come to terms with Vodafone if they haven’t already.