Put yourself in China’s place. If you were in charge of China’s future DVD technology, would you be seriously tempted by HD DVD technology from Toshiba, or by Blu-ray.
At Faultline we think the answer is obvious, and headlines that would have it that Toshiba is licensing its technology to Chinese DVD player makers is highly unlikely. Sure one or two of them might consider making the players, but why would they when they can almost certainly gain access to huge export markets if they wait a while work with Blu-ray.
They could then make the high volume devices that will sell in the US and in Europe for high values, giving them a huge export market, rather than build devices that no-one outside China wants.
The New York Times, among other papers reported the statements from Toshiba that it was negotiating with Chinese DVD makers, but we think these are the death struggles of mortally wounded standard.
Even if there were millions of Chinese made HD DVD devices ready for export, given that the bulk of the content companies have all committed to Blu-ray exclusively, these devices could all be left on a retail shelf somewhere.
Two of China’s largest DVD makers, Amoi and JiangKui, which build devices for other CE manufacturing brands were cited in the NY Times article as saying they would begin making devices using Toshiba’s HD-DVD format and said this was because of Toshiba’s greater willingness to share its technology. Sony will make devices in China, but not by licensing its technology to contract manufacturers, instead it has its own plants there.
When these cheap Chinese made HD DVD devices hit the market they are expected to cost as little as 50% of Toshiba’s equivalent devices, but with no content to play on them, they will be unlikely to sell and quickly withdrawn.