Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 November 2005

Qualcomm fires at Nokia over patents out of anti-trust frustration

Qualcomm responded to the multiple anti-trust attacks it received last week in Europe, at the hands of Broadcom, Ericsson, NEC, Nokia, Panasonic and Texas Instruments and Nokia, by issuing its own legal action, against Nokia, claiming patent infringement on 12 of its patents, which it claims are used in GSM extensions, Edge and GPRS.

Nokia responded within hours, not just rebutting the claim but ridiculing it, saying that given that it has never had a discussion with Qualcomm about this, and that terms have never even been proposed, it seems hardly fair and non-discriminatory to sue first and negotiate afterwards. Nokia made the point that before adopting any technology for a standard, a clause about fair and non-discriminatory licensing terms is always added.

Nokia further said ‘the timing of this lawsuit and the comments of Qualcomm’s general counsel that a cooperative resolution of these issues is unlikely, when the patents have not been verified and licensing terms have not yet been offered or discussed, is completely inconsistent with the basic licensing principles to which Qualcomm is obligated.’

It was in effect being shown up as a blatant tit-for-tat gut reaction, that has little to do with the proper approach to licensing patents.

Qualcomm has applied to a US court to stop Nokia, from selling certain handsets in the United States, and demanded unspecified monetary damages.

The suit that kicked it all off is that begun in May when Broadcom filed a patent infringement lawsuit against, Qualcomm, claiming it used its intellectual property in products that combine video, VoIP, Bluetooth and other functions within one cellphone chipset. It filed another separate action that it has also deliberately imported chips that infringed on its patents and called for an immediate injunction.

Broadcom followed this up two weeks later with a US anti-trust action claiming that patent licenses are cheaper for companies that buy Qualcomm’s CDMA chips than for those that make their own.

Given that Qualcomm controls 90% of the CDAM cellular market, if it does offer discriminatory terms, it will be an open and shut case, but it has to be proven.

At the time Broadcom said ‘Qualcomm has demanded from Broadcom a wide array of terms that are designed to cripple Broadcom as a competitor.’ However, the complaint says it cannot provide details of this, for fear of violating Qualcomm’s nondisclosure agreements.
What in effect Broadcom is saying is that in order to get rights to Qualcomm technology, it has to give up even more valuable rights to its own intellectual property, with Qualcomm requiring Broadcom to reveal “detailed and sensitive” price information about their dealings with their customers.

Last week Broadcom has followed its US antitrust complaints against Qualcomm by joining with Ericsson, Nokia and others to bring similar accusations before the European Commission. With other major intellectual property holders feeling the pressure to reduce the royalty burden that keeps 3G equipment prices high, they are keen to bring Qualcomm into line and reduce its potential market hold in W-CDMA.

One of the issues here is that Qualcomm holds far less of the W-CDMA patents than other players such as Nokia and Ericsson, but wants more for them than other companies are charging.

Qualcomm has long been an intellectual property bully, but has largely steered the right side of the legal line, now as players such as Broadcom, strong in Bluetooth, seek to slide into the growing and lucrative cellular markets, there is less money to be shared around. Apart from methods of manufacture, Broadcom holds relatively few core patents in any technology it makes chips for.

But lashing out by Qualcomm at Nokia seems designed to just infuriate the Finnish handset maker. Qualcomm had none of the patents considered essential to GSM. Given that Qualcomm was formed in 1985 and the committee to establish GSM sat first in 1982 and produced its first spec in 1989, that’s hardly surprising.

But GPRS which first went commercial in 1999 is another matter, and Qualcomm has suddenly claimed that it has patents that are essential to this and to EDGE which was only thought about in 2000.

Qualcomm said that Nokia has used some of its CDMA technology to improve networks based on GSM, so that they too could achieve faster speeds for data services, such as video calls and Internet downloads. Qualcomm also said the Nokia lawsuit affected 11 Qualcomm patents and one belonging to its subsidiary, SnapTrack.

‘Until recently, we had been led to believe that these issues might be resolved cooperatively and amicably,’ Qualcomm Senior Vice President Louis Lupin said in a statement. Of course his statement and Nokia’s can’t both be accurate and the gloves are already off in this contest between two companies that don’t even have to pretend to like each other.

While Faultline is not about mobile technology, it is about media going digital, and GPRS and EDGE are defensive ploys to squeeze almost broadband data rates out of phones, and more importantly Qualcomm is likely to have a future say in 4G and OFDM, in which it has amassed substantial patents, which is the signal carrier for some brands of Wi-Fi, WiMAX, Powerline and most forms of Mobile TV.

The likely outcome is that this will either be dealt with by the US Justice Department or the European Commission, and the time frame for resolution will be at least four years.