Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 November 2005

SBC CEO lobbies against ‘unaffiliated’ VoIP ‘Freeriders’

Quite a few reports have come to us of SBC chairman and CEO, Ed Whitacre and his now infamous outburst where he stated at a recent conference, that because SBC owns the pipes that reach out to US homes, then everyone, including Google, Yahoo and Vonage, are going to have to pay SBC for accessing his customers. He describes them all as ‘freeriders’ that have no cable in the ground.

Whitacre is perhaps a little touched and yet at the some time out of touch. The FCC has made it abundantly clear that VoIP services will remain unregulated and that blocking VoIP services is a no-no. So that deals with Vonage.

Secondly his customers, some 6 million of them, amounting to something like $1.4 billion of SBC’s annual revenue, pay for access to the internet. If they don’t get that access, or if it is interfered with, or if they get substandard access, they will swap their DSL line for either a cable line or an emerging services from Powerline or wireless. If they all did that Whitacre would be looking for a job.

As it is, his own RBOC competition may come looking for his customers out of their territories, by using wireless technologies and existing spectrum holdings, and so will Sprint-Nextel.

But worse than that, if he keeps saying these things, then Google or Yahoo or someone, will build their own network to the home and go into competition with the SBC access network, and take ALL of the SBC business away. It wouldn’t be just Whitacre that would lose his job if this happened.

Whitacre is mostly talking about VoIP and has made this rant before, as has Verizon, but he failed completely to do anything about Skype or Vonage and it is likely that he is just lobbying for support, and fully understands the economic pressures that his business is under.

What he wants to achieve is for the FCC to say that VoIP is an unregulated activity, and then SBC can go into business as a VoIP provider and quietly destabilize other VoIP provider offerings. SBC could then maintain its localized monopoly post VoIP. What the FCC should do is carefully police any action that any RBOC takes to prevent the free flow of VoIP traffic in and out of RBOC networks and make sure that this is not a repeat of the way in which the RBOCs saw off the CLECs.