Despite us having trouble finding reasons why Scientific Atlanta was up for sale, Cisco duly announced this week that it had agreed to acquire the US’s second largest set-top, video distribution and video systems integration business, paying some $6.9 billion for it, paid in both cash and debt.
The deal initially pummeled Cisco’s share price for a couple of days but it has since recovered all its losses. The story that is being put out is that Cisco needs to be bigger in consumer and this balances it against its enterprise strengths. But that’s all too glib and we don’t really buy it.
Cisco is paying $43 a share for each share of Scientific-Atlanta (SFA), and is assuming any outstanding share options. That means that the price paid is $6.9 billion which works out at about $5.3 billion after you consider that SFA oodles of cash in the bank.
Cisco says the deal with be complete by the third quarter of Cisco’s fiscal year 2006 which means by 30th of April 2006 and says the deal will be neutral to its 2006 earnings, but accretive in 2007.
The deal has been approved by both Boards and although it needs to clear various approvals, it doesn’t look like there are any real reasons for them not being granted.
‘Video is emerging as the key strategic application in the service provider triple play bundle of consumer entertainment, communication and online services,’ said John Chambers, president and chief executive officer of Cisco Systems. ‘The combination of Cisco and Scientific-Atlanta brings unmatched experience and innovation in delivering large scale video systems and networks, and the addition of Scientific-Atlanta further extends Cisco’s leadership in the service provider market. Moreover, Cisco’s international presence and IP leadership will also create strategic synergies that accelerate the combined growth opportunity.’
It’s true that SFA is a beginner outside of the US, and Cisco can probably help here. It is already being called upon in many IPTV rollouts for core router capabilities, so why not, it argues, push the rest of the IPTV offering, and, like Microsoft and Alcatel, go end to end.
Well, for one thing SFA currently has almost all of its revenue from the cable TV community, not IPTV, although it has a piece of the SBC Communications contract to introduce IPTV to 18 million Americans. And cable is still a long way from being fundamentally IP driven. But Cisco will be a handy helper once cable decides to go down that route.
Outside of the US, there is a lot of IPTV activity and to date Cisco has really been a bit part player. At the IBC conference earlier this year it told us that it is now prepared to configure its core routers to be asynchronous to support networks that are laboring in getting video traffic out to the edge, rather than traveling equally fast in both directions.
Cisco made a great play out of saying that already 10s of millions of IPTV subscribers are ultimately routed by its devices.
Cisco said then that it pictured a world where its Carrier Routing System (CRS 1) is configured with a kind of super head end behind it, delivering dynamic multicasts throughout the internet and caching them at key points.
Given that one of the key elements that SFA makes are those Head ends, the part of an IPTV system that receives satellite feeds and re-compresses and cleans them, and then sends them on their way, all in real time, the SFA deal seems to fit in with this view.
Chambers continued making comments about the digital home and what goes on inside it, rather than he process of getting content to the home. So should we expect some unholy alliance between the retailed Linksys wi-fi devices and the SFA set tops? Well possibly, but tightly coupling a set top with a bulk standard wi-fi device seems worth a lot less than $7 billion.
Following the close of the transaction, Scientific-Atlanta will become a division of the Routing and Service Provider Technology Group under the leadership of Cisco Senior Vice President Mike Volpi, so very clearly not a part of Linksys.
Back in July Cisco swooped for Danish consumer electronics company KiSS, paying just $61 million and taking its first step into the consumer electronics markets. It appeared at the time to be broadening its Linksys brand into a fully fledged supplier of flat TV screens, DVD players, DVR’s, set tops and home networking. But the SFA deal shuold not be confused with this, as it is altogether more strategic.