Californian DRM company Navio must be giving its investors nightmares. It has just taken on board a second round of $25 million, but is now openly claiming it will break into Apple’s Fairplay DRM, so that other music stores can insert DRM protected content onto iPods.
Navio describes itself as a rights-based commerce company that wants to fundamentally change the way digital commerce is conducted, well offering to hack another DRM on behalf of online music stores is perhaps not the best way to go about convincing everyone that you’re serious about securing content.
Apple Fairplay is notoriously lightweight and can be cracked by encryption and DRM experts, but it is no pushover for the average music fan. That’s more or less how Apple wanted it designed. Also the iPod can both have content that it protects and which is not protected and it will record, hold and play MP3 files without affording them the protection of its Fairplay DRM.
In other words any music store can allow their music to play on an iPod, but only at the risk of it being pirated, and that would result in the music store losing the support of its record labels.
In order to get under the skin of Fairplay, music needs be in the AAC format and dupe the iPod system into thinking that it was supplied by iTunes music store. For this it needs to carry the correct identifier fields etc.. and be correctly encrypted.
The opportunity this presents for Navio is for it to act as a gateway for other music stores to get in on the iPod phenomena, but at the same time it presents the problem that any such system will be constantly at the mercy of Apple.The company can block music stores from working with its iPods by downloading incompatible updates every time it makes changes to its iTunes system.
Last year RealNetworks wrote its own code to do this, and Apple immediately stopped it from working. RealNetworks says that it has since got around the Apple fix and the war goes on. Technically it may be a legal breach of the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, but Apple is unlikely to take legal action. Apple makes all of its profits out of the iPod, not out of iTunes record sales so it quite likes the idea of more music being aimed at the device, but doesn’t want labels seeing other music stores as just as valid as iTunes, because it risks losing its control.
Apple also reasons that if it openly licensed the Fairplay DRM, then it would start appearing on other MP3 players and Apple would sell far less iPods.
Last week Digital Video Recorder specialist TiVo opened the way to placing files onto an iPod that do not use its DRM protection. Instead the company placed files that had unique identifiers, called watermarks on each copy, which can identify the TiVo box it was downloaded from. This doesn’t stop copying as Fairplay does, but anyone pirating using this approach is easily caught, so it discourages it.
If the TiVo approach is acceptable to the content companies, then Navio will have no market for its iPod work around. Navio claims to be working with a number of studios, and record labels as well as its usual customer base of cellcos.