Once upon a time you could look in the newspapers and find out not only what was on TV that day, but also what was playing at the local cinema. That, more or less, was how you found video content and it was fixed at a point in time for viewing, and available from just one location.
Today video entertainment is more like soda. You can buy one when you like, whenever you feel like it. You can take it home and view it, watch it halfway through and save it for later, order it online for delivery, buy one in a bar or on the street and share it with whomever you like. However you want, wherever you want.
But can you imagine a world where you’re not sure if a film is out on Blu-ray or HD DVD or old style DVD, if it has been released into celluloid or digital cinema format, or if it’s available online for rent or for purchase as a download and whether or not that download works on a PC, an iPod, a TV or if it can be download directly to play on some set top boxes or DVRs. Can you get a version of the content in High Definition, Standard definition, or QVGA to play on your phone handset, downloaded or as a flash memory version. Is there a UMD (mini DVD) for your Sony PSP of the film you want? You might find that all the time it was playing on your local subscription VoD service, or worse still, it was available on a website as a free ad supported video.
A number of deals announced this week, the new iTunes content from NBC, the release of Family Guy to the IGN and MySpace web sites, the CinemaNow Japan deal with Warner Brothers, HDNet offering HD content to SureWest IPTV system, Viacom putting its TV shows on Verizon phones and British Telecom licensing Paramount films, these deals all show that each week content deals are being cut that will lead to this type of confusion.
Even the quest to break up Time Warner and separate out the AOL brand, is borne out of a feeling that either MSN or Google are further down the route of using web technology to bring a viable video model to the internet, than the previously subscription oriented AOL. Effectively AOL has been caught in the crossfire of attempts to put TV on the internet along with the massive shift in advertising revenues that naturally follow this move.
In the end, if any kind of architecture emerges to help the beleaguered consumer, it will have to deal with all of these formats at once.
What we have at the moment is a continual haranguing of customers with special offers, using whatever means of communication is favored by the particular content owner. What consumers need is a unified resource that looks something like the diagram below, fronted by some automated video search, but taking in conventional retail stock databases.
It is likely to take a long time, but this is a potential endpoint that someone should start working towards today, in order that something resembling this will be in place in five years time.
At the moment there are far too many touchpoints, and no data cross over. If Google has an episode of a TV series showing for the next week, it will advertise it to Google users. If iTunes has a special on ‘Lost,’ it can put it on the iTunes store front. If Amazon has just got the latest DVD in it will advertise it on Amazon, just as Sony’s PSP web site will be used to ship out the UMD version of a film.
None of this is consumer centric. Instead it is all supplier centric. Obviously Amazon doesn’t want to let Apple advertise that there is an online version of a video on iTunes. And Sony doesn’t want to let a PSP customer know about a DVD special offer at Amazon for the same content.
But in the end, these markets all risk being be undernourished due to their fragmentation, and so it would pay if there was an ‘honest broker’ to emerge that has a relationship with each of the format owners.
We are seeing the fragmentation of our video supply market and that means that the current revenues spread over cinema, TV advertising and retail DVD will be spread further and wider over many more formats using both rental, purchase, free to air and free to web advertising driven models, VoD, mobile telephony and portable player markets.
In the end it should never matter whether or not a particular film is available, as this should move towards being a real time distribution market where all products that ever existed are available in one format or another. A US TV channel will have to pay a lot more to buy exclusive rights, and will increasingly opt to share rights with delayed web or iPod access in order to share the costs or have them offset by extra revenues.
As this happens we can either move to a situation where all of the formats compete for attention, or when they all collaborate. If the content owner is inordinately greedy and just wants more and more revenue, it is likely that some of these routes to market will become starved as they all compete for attention and all separately bear the burden of high content costs.
But there is just as likely to be a number of enlightened content players that are happy to take less money for each of the emerging formats individually, as long as the total is collectively more that what the earned before. This will allows all of the formats to flourish.
It will lead to innovative deals which relate costs more and more directly to the number of people that view a particular piece of content through a particular format, as a percentage of the total number that view it, offset against total costs. Clearly it won’t be an exact science, but new deal shapes will work towards it.
If your medium adds 5% to the viewing figure, somehow you need to get to pay 5% of the content creation costs. If that happens, then broadcast and cable TV won’t worry quite so much if the web takes away viewers, as it will get a cost reduction as a result of it, in what is its singularly largest cost ‘ content.
That may sound idealistic, but we see this occurring over a long period of time, and it appears fairly inevitable. The way it will work in real life is that as more video is offered on the web, or on iTunes or over VoD networks, the more content owners will look to increase payment. As numbers fall in conventional TV, and ad revenues with them, the incumbent TV operators will look to lower their content charges. In time it will even out based on what is economically feasible. If more people in total watch a piece of content, it should yield higher earnings, if less people watch it, it should yield less. The less profitable forms of content will fade, the more profitable flourish.
Of course fragmentation will be into far more layers than the diagram we have shown. Each of the boxes represents multiple entrants, not just one. For every iTunes, there will be five other online services for portable players, for every mobile operator offering video content, there will be at least a further 3 others for each given territory.
However this week’s content announcement shows how the pace has rapidly increased in the segment since the historical Video iPod deal earlier this year. Soon there will be so many announcements they won’t make the news per se, but just make up the promotional noise at each of the players’ store fronts.
In another story this week we have the example of Director Steven Soderbergh releasing his next film to cinema, DVD and VoD all at the same, time. In two years time this might include mobile TV, UMD, iPod and online as well.
NBC Universal has offered episodes of TV series Law & Order, The Office, The Tonight Show with Jay Leno and Monk, and others, to iTunes, while News Corp which actually owns the IGN network of games web sites and MySpace, has released its own hugely popular Fox program ‘Family Guy,’ for $1.99 each (same price as iTunes).
Other deals include CinemaNow, finally getting its act together outside the US with Japanese licensing for Warner Brothers films. CinemaNow has been US bound for some years and although it has tried licensing its entire system outside to companies in Europe in Italy and Germany, the content licenses have never previously been forthcoming. Now it looks like they are. And if international content is available for CinemaNow, then it will be available for many other sources in 2006.
Another content deal this week claims a first in HD IPTV (see separate story) in which SureWest has licensed Mark Cuban’s HDNet and HDNet Movies.
Going in the other direction, in content that requires lower definition, Verizon is putting video content from Viacom TV shows through its V Cast mobile video service, with everything from short clips of Viacom properties to full-length TV episodes.
Finally British Telecom has begun to unveil the kind of content that will emerge on its soon to be released Microsoft IPTV powered VoD service, with deals at BBC Worldwide, Paramount and Warner Music Group.