Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2005

Case makes a case for independent AOL

Steve Case, the man that threw AOL together with Time Warner, in one of the most financially disastrous mergers in US corporate history, has come out and backed the renegade shareholders that want to break it up.

Case wrote the opinion in a column in the Washington Post newspaper and by throwing in his lot with outspoken investor Carl Icahn, they each speak for around 3% of the stock of the company. Although this is not a high percentage, it is thought to be the largest block of stock in the hands of just Case, Icahn and a few hedge funds that support them.

Both oppose any kind of plan between AOL and either Google or Microsoft, and Icahn has threatened to sue directors if they commit the company to a deal of this type which reduces investor value.

The trend on Wall Street for content companies is a downward price spiral and splitting off parts of Viacom, followed by the process of splitting it into two separate companies, currently underway, has set the expectation of quite a few investors. Our own Faultline concept was originally drawn from the idea that digital delivery would hurt some parts of the content food chain and boost others and these conglomerates own properties pulling in different directions.

AOL as a independent would either have to stand on its own two feet with new technologically literate leadership or it could make an extremely tasty morsel, sold off to one of the other large portal players.

Case now says that he thinks the component parts of Time Warner might be worth more than the whole, allowing AOL to set off on its own path,
but it does as well to remember Case has shares in the whole operation, not just the AOL element of it, so his fortune is protected either way.

The Board of Time Warner is of course not in favor of the move, and the fact that chief executive Richard Parsons is the man that replaced Case at the helm, somewhat acrimoniously, may have something to do with Case’s comments.

Icahn wants to apply pressure, gain support and wage a proxy fight for control of the company, but most observers think that as long as the current Board is careful not to upset investors with any sudden, unpopular move, success for Icahn is unlikely.