Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2005

HPNA: The Fly in MoCA’s Ointment

Remember HPNA – the Home Phoneline Networking Alliance – that was working to develop technology standards so the home’s copper telephone wires could be used for networking? Well, it’s been abandoned by most, but Israeli chipmaker Coppergate has kept an assemblage that includes names such as AT&T (nee SBC), Scientific-Atlanta, Motorola, Samsung and others. It is supposed to be supported in the Microsoft IPTV designs for AT&T, in one of its later versions.

In addition to working over copper wiring, HPNA is also said to work over coax as well. It seems SBC Labs, er, uh, that’s probably AT&T Labs now, is still involved because of its concern that some homes don’t have coax cable installed and that AT&T might not have access to the coax network in many apartment buildings. It wants a copper wire solution for those situations.

AT&T’s plan of record calls for MoCA on the first implementation of its Lightspeed network, but it’s requested HPNA capability if the field trials pan out.

Reportedly, the initial HPNA tests at AT&T did not go well due to limited performance in both throughput and outlet coverage. Lots of the copper wiring in homes and apartments is pretty old. However, work is still being done on improvements.

Coppergate is the only HPNA 3.0 chip vendor we could find.
It’s certainly understandable that the industry wants a back door in the Alamo (that’s an Americanism for second source) in case MoCA falters. Unless HPNA can get quickly up to speed and robustness on a coax network, it’ll find MoCA with too much momentum to stop in the coax world.