The statement, issued days before Christmas, that Google would continue to hold AOL’s hand, represents a crushing defeat for Microsoft’s online ambitions. After a long, drawn out phony war conducted in the press, with Microsoft executives continually hinting that it was in the driving seat, the software giant lost the deal. Google will also invest $1 Billion for a 5% stake in AOL, putting a price of $20 billion on the online giant, potentially boosting the overall Time Warner share value. However so far, since the deal was struck, that share value has fallen by around 5% to $82 billion. Google will be the only shareholder in AOL other than Time Warner.
Not a single seasoned campaigner in the analyst and press world was prepared to bet against Microsoft, but after this deal, they will in future. If Time Warner, which in many walks of life has been buddying up to Microsoft, chose not to seal a technology deal, then it is unlikely that any other online or content partner will prefer Microsoft when Google is an option.
Was this just a case of Time Warner using fear of Microsoft to get better terms from Google? Perhaps, but now the deal is struck, it is impossible to see any other potential online partner big enough to help Microsoft achieve its goals in advertising and online search and it will have to go it alone.
The new deal replaces a three year old deal between AOL and Google, that few people realized would become so pivotal when it was initially signed. New aspects of the deal include the ability for AOL to use Google’s search advertising technology; the right for AOL sales teams to put advertising on the Google network; more AOL content being fed to Google web crawlers and a collaboration on the all important video search field.
What this will mean is that if a user searches on Google and there are AOL hits available, a special section of the search page will be devoted to AOL.
Beyond that, Google Talk and AIM instant messaging customers will be able to communicate with each other.
Time Warner Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Dick Parsons said: “We’re very pleased to build significantly on our special relationship with Google in a way that will meaningfully strengthen AOL’s position in the fast growing online advertising business and help drive more advertisers to its web properties.’
The deal is widely seen as a shortcut in helping AOL shift from a paid subscription business model to free content with paid advertising. Equally at the heart of the deal, alongside AOL subscriber numbers, is Time Warner’s valuable content offerings which will in turn strengthen Google as Time Warner opens its back catalog to Google.
Under the strategic alliance, Google will continue providing search technology to AOL’s network of Internet properties worldwide and there is talk of expanding the new partnership to Time Warner’s other advertising opportunities.
This entire deal happens with the background of a very noisy battle between Time Warner shareholder activist Carl Icahn, and the management of the company. Icahn wanted AOL to partner with smaller online businesses such as eBay and Diller’s InterActive corporation and engage their internet savvy management, or sell AOL off completely, making the point that Dick Parsons, CEO of Time Warner, has no skill in running an online business like AOL.
Which is why it is important that Time Warner has retained management control and what it calls ‘full strategic flexibility over AOL,’ which means it can still sell AOL if it has to, or float it at some stage in the future, if conditions change. This dangles that carrot of a $20 billion windfall in front of Time Warner shareholders, without actually committing to such a deal.
Financially this deal cements around $500 million of existing revenues for AOL, something that may have been in some jeopardy, or at least uncertainty, if AOL had signed with Microsoft.
In the end Time Warner management must have sensed that Microsoft’s main reason for doing the deal was to block success for Google, not bring success to Time Warner shareholders.
Microsoft senior management, especially Steve Ballmer, who has shown time and time again that he has an unhealthy pre-occupation with going up against Google, will be rabid at the loss of this deal as it shuts Microsoft into a rare, and distant third place (after Yahoo) in internet advertising, and gives Google an even better platform to directly attack Microsoft’s core software business, by giving away software to a wider audience.
Certainly the interoperability between AOL and Google instant messengers will present a challenge to the continued growth of Microsoft’s highly accepted IM product.
But the overwhelming feeling is that Google was head to head against Microsoft for the first time in a deal that would typically go Microsoft’s way in the past, and it found the strategy to win the day. That in itself is a turning point, and a testimony to how powerful it has become as a brand.
Up until now Google has avoided head on confrontations with Microsoft except where consumer action would win the day.
One element that may have swung the deal slightly in Google’s favor was the fact that the AOL staff were keen to work alongside the Google culture, not Microsoft’s. AOL founder Steve Case was seen as backing a deal with Google deal as well.