Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 January 2006

AT&T quietly launches IPTV, amid rumors of EchoStar merger

AT&T quietly launched its much heralded and slightly delayed IPTV service in its home town of San Antonio and over the coming months will drive up trial customer numbers. Initially it is just a limited number including staff members and a handful of commercial subscribers and the company is talking more about fine tuning right now than mass rollout.

The launch wasn’t actually announced, but word leaked out in a variety of US news sources, including Red Herring, and the detail is sketchy. There are an initial 200 TV channels with all the usual suspects HBO, MTV, ESPN, Discovery and Disney Channels etc… and the company is saying that eventually it will have 1,000 channels.

Now that’s insanity. Each person can only watch 1 channel at a time, and commonly TV favorites lists extend to no more than 12 channels in total.

It will be another few months until the service is rolled out aggressively and in the meantime AT&T will add more channels some of them HDTV, and video on demand.

AT&T answered some questions from reporters that found out about the trial, but not many. The compression scheme still seems to be up for grabs, and while most Microsoft customers have gone for H.264/MPEG 4, AT&T is still refusing to say and may be opting for Microsoft’s VC-1. The problem with that is that it doesn’t have a licensing scheme yet, since it is tied up in a patent pooling argument and it may never be legally licensed.

Subscribers will receive up to three set-top boxes with built-in digital video recorders, but AT&T is not saying what it is charging for these services beyond stating that pricing will be competitive with local cable.

Another announcement this week from 2Wire, the AT&T partner that has been chosen to provide a home portal (using VDSL2) for the service made interesting reading, when it said that a new version of the portal could be installed without getting into the home.

It fits in a hardened, weather-resistant enclosure and decreases the complexity and cost of carrier “truck roll” during installations.

By transferring intelligent gateway functions and all service and network terminations to the side of the house, the 2Wire iNID eliminates the need to bring DSL into the house. The location at the side of the house, near the existing telephone Network Interface Device, also allows for an easy connection to be made between the iNID’s integrated voice over IP function and the home’s existing phone wiring.

A customer-installable power module inside the home powers the iNID through the home’s existing phone wiring, while the iNID’s integrated battery provides backup power.

Back in December AT&T announced a $43 million, one-year contract for 2Wire to deliver the gateway to its AT&T U-verse customers and it would be a no brainer for them to upgrade to this new external equipment to lower truck roll costs.

AT&T announced in September agreements with Motorola and Scientific-Atlanta to provide set-top boxes for AT&T U-verse TV which will connect directly to the 2Wire residential gateway.

In the meantime US financial analysts, struggling after a quiet Christmas floated the idea that AT&T might buy the number 2 US satellite TV company, EchoStar

While such a takeover isn’t impossible, simply on the basis that senior executives of major organizations are not immune from making crazy decisions, we just thought we’d register a number of reasons why we think it would be madness to attempt such a deal.

First off the takeover would likely be hostile. The Dish network is not for sale and to be successful that would mean a premium of around 35% over today’s share price.

Sales of Dish through AT&T have gone up this year, so it is becoming an increasingly important partnership to AT&T, and in the last nine months it brought in around $165 million of revenue. But the company has changed the deal with EchoStar and will no longer be recording much in the way of revenues except commission for the sales.

It is also reducing its effort by targeting sale of this service only in markets where the rate of customer defections to other services is highest. So in effect it needs to scale down the EchoStar offering except in territories where it is needed, because its own IPTV service, working with Alcatel and Microsoft is due soon, at huge expense.

Analysts have been caught saying that at $13 billion this is a real snip for AT&T, but they would be unlikely to be given a clean run at the target, and a white knight would be sure to drive the price up.

The SBC Communications part of AT&T cut a deal to offer joint billing and merged sales from July 2003, and put $1 billion into EchoStar as an investment.

If AT&T acquired EchoStar and its Dish network the most likely outcome would be that it had wasted huge amounts of its time negotiating content relationships for its IPTV offerings that can instead have relied upon the EchoStar know how, and that it is offering two competing systems and carrying two separate sets of costs. That could make its $6 billon Project Lightspeed unnecessary and lead to its share value falling.

There IS an argument that this is what AT&T SHOULD have done, but now it is part way to building outs fiber extensions to its network, so that 18 million homes each have fiber within 5,000 feet, it is too late.

Also, given the number of times the Microsoft inspired IPTV effort at AT&T has been said to be delayed, what kind of desperate signal would a bid for EchoStar send out? It may well be interpreted as a ‘giving up’ on the IPTV effort, which could be potentially calamitous to its share price. Not that we believe the IPTV IS delayed, but others are prepare to believe it.

In favor of the idea, when the company was SBC it did bid for DirecTV but lost out to News Corp.