Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 January 2006

What Apple needs to do

The announcements at CES last week, multiple online movie stores, multiple music services, multiple tie ups between content and platform vendors, present Apple with a huge challenge. It has to open up the video iPod Fairplay DRM to key set top players.

We are not suggesting the same thing that many other people have suggested, which is that Apple licenses Fairplay to other makers of portable players, but that it selectively licenses enough know-how so that set top makers can deliver content into the safe hands of Fairplay on the iPod. That way TV can be securely shifted onto an iPod, instead of insecurely as it is today.

Such a licensing contract could only be offered, as it was to Motorola on the ROKR phone, for the purposes of import into Fairplay, and strictly not for building a portable player that can emulate an iPod, potentially leading to a fall in iPod sales.

There are now at least ten different ways that content can be moved from a broadcast TV service onto a PC and out onto the iPod, and with the exception of the TiVo way of doing things, using watermarking to make the copy traceable, none of them add any form of copy protection. This places Apple in the invidious position of being the weakest link in a chain of defenses against piracy, and pretty soon content owners will begin speaking out against the video iPod.

The content sold by Apple is protected, albeit with a fairly weak DRM which has had its insides publicly published on various web sites, but it requires a positive act of piracy to get content out from under it. But the broadcast content that is being placed onto the iPod is afforded no such protection and each piece of software that is making it easy to place these files onto an iPod, is doing all the basic steps of making sure that it is digitally encoded so that it is in the perfect condition for piracy.

If Apple fails to move at least this far, it will become marginalized in the video market and merely retain the online music market, and that will be as big a disaster for Apple as failing to license its operating system back in the early 1980s.