The US Patent office appeals process is now saying that Macrovision was the first to invent some key aspects of DRM, not Intertrust.
The Macrovision patents were purchased from bankrupt software house AudioSoft International, which wrote the DRM product MediaDNA.
The two companies filed for similar patents about 12 days apart and the assumption was always that Intertrust could prove it invented all the ideas first, so that its patent filings were safe in the US, where invention date is key, though severely weakened outside of the US where filing date is more important.
But now a judgment of priority (first to invent) has been filed in favor of Macrovision against InterTrust Technologies. Back in April last year a whole swathe of DRM patents were issued in Intertrust’s favor stopping Macrovision from claiming them, despite the slightly earlier filing date.
But at the time Macrovision said, ‘The ruling concluded that certain of InterTrust’s patent claims have priority over the Macrovision claims; however, this is an ongoing process with other portions of the interference action still under review by the Panel. The InterTrust interference action has no bearing on patents outside the US and the essential international DRM patent applications mentioned above are proceeding to issuance in Europe and Japan, unaffected by the outcome of the US patent interference action.’
While it seems a shame to us that one company that actually invented something is going to lose out to a company that only bought the assets of a bankrupt firm, it does appear that this case will weaken Intertrust’s grip on DRM patents both in the US and outside.
It is likely that the only way anyone can be sure they have suitably licensed DRM patents is to go to both Intertrust and Macrovision (and potentially ContentGuard) and better still Macrovision may have to be invited into existing patent pools that operate in Intertrust’s favor.