Brand is a deeply strange thing that turns people a little bit insane. Google has a fabulous brand. It all starts on the Google home page when it offers alternative search under the title ‘I’m feeling lucky,’ a quote borrowed almost directly from the film Dirty Harry (Ask yourself are you feeling lucky today. Well are you punk?)
We get the impression that the consequences of using a different search engine are onerous. We like the up front style of it and think that Google is ‘on our side.’ Well wake up everyone, it’s just marketing. It doesn’t mean that Google is always on the side of the consumer, especially when the consumer wants a world full of free, pirated, content.
So it came as no surprise to us at Faultline that Google is to introduce its own DRM. Our first thought was that the company was insane if it didn’t use a piece of software that had already been tried and tested and passed adequate by the content companies that make up Hollywood. But then a day or two later when it transpired, courtesy of DRM Watch, that the DRM came from none other than DivX, it all clicked.
Here’s what we wrote about DivX in August 2004, ‘If anyone out there (like Faultline) thinks that there is room and enthusiasm for film download services like Movielink and CinemaNow, but ones which are properly run and which actually want to grow, they could do worse than take a long hard look at what DivX is up to.’
DivX had first written a codec optimized for smallest file sizes, rather than thinnest bandwidth. It had found that P2P pirates used its free codec to compress pirated works, and it found itself with a bad name in Hollywood. The company went to the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) and asked what it could do to get its hands on first run, film content.
It was told to introduce its own Digital Rights Management system, which it spent three years writing and which received the blessing of the MPAA.
‘We had to write our own Digital Rights Management software which works by first registering each CE device online and uses our remote servers to store encryption keys and permissions. Once a piece of content has been given permission to play on a registered player it no longer has to be online, but the first time it is played, it needs to connect. But we make that process completely seamless for the customer,’ a DivX spokesman told us in 2004.
The DRM system can then support multiple business models such as 5 day rental or a set number of views or even outright purchase, depending on what content owners require.
So does all this mean that the major studios are about ready to release content for delivery under DiVX care? ‘It’s been a long process but we think that the major studios are about to give us access,’ the company said at the time, but it was wrong, perhaps two years too early.
Hollywood has been waiting for someone else to come along (with a nice brand) who would play by the rules, but make the whole thing much bigger than DivX ever could, and that company may well be Google.
While the rest of the media world has spent this week berating Google for stooping so low as to take on ANY kind of DRM, and lumping them in with pro-DRM groups such as Microsoft and the MPAA, we’ve spent the time thinking just what a good move this is for Google.
DivX went on to embed its codec in chips from MediaTek, Philips, LSI Logic and ESS and these in turn have been embedded in consumer electronic devices such as DVD players and DVRs from Panasonic, Philips, Toshiba, JVC, Pioneer and Thomson. All very quietly.
The vision is that protected video content can come down a broadband line, straight into a consumer electronic device, without touching a PC or media center, and play, be saved and stored and even burned into DVD and not risk piracy, because the content is all encrypted and the decryption keys do not copy when a DVD is burned, they live in safety inside each registered device.
And it almost worked. DivX managed to get around 20 million devices installed, mostly in Europe, with hooks into its Codec and DRM. What never happened is that the studios never licensed either DivX or its partners to have the premium content that such a service needed. Enter Google and that’s where we are so far.
Now we don’t yet know how much of this vision Google is going to take up, maybe it has just adopted the DRM portion and will deliver content to Intel Viiv PCs and bypass the 20 million installed DivX devices. But that would be looking a gift horse in the mouth rather.
TVs, DVD players branded with ‘Google inside’ which automatically link to the new Google commercial video marketplace, with content from CBS, the National Basketball Association, Sony BMG, ITN, and a to be announced film studio, might cause quite a stir.
At least shareholders in DivX will be finally able to see the kind of interest in the company that they always thought it deserved, and the Google brand is more than big enough to survive being tainted with the dirty brush of DRM.