Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 January 2006

Sprint Nextel hints at TDD 2.5GHz network for mobile TV

Sprint Nextel was always going to do something quite special with its 2.5 GHz spectrum holdings in the US, and an investment it made this week points it in an entirely new direction which, if it materializes, will harmonize all of its services, voice, video and data over a single chunk of spectrum.

We already know that Sprint Nextel has cut a deal to deliver a subset of cable TV channels to mobile phones for a collection of US cable operators, namely Comcast, Time Warner Cable, and Cox.

But its technology choice was and still is a tricky one. Mobile telephony falls into European standards around UMTS and US standards in Qualcomm controlled CDMA. Neither currently work in 2.5 GHz.

WiMAX can work in 2.5GHz and there may be more auctions in Europe in the next two years that will devote some 2.5 GHz spectrum to mobile, but WiMAX so far has no built-in multicasting standard for WiMAX base stations, although Samsung has talked about it. Using either Qualcomm’s MediaFLO or Modeo’s DVB-H network would have meant offering TV in someone else’s spectrum under someone else’s control which might also be offered to Sprint’s competitors and anyway that would ruin the deal with the cable companies.

But this week Sprint invested a further $10 million in IP Wireless and at the same time declared a trial using IP Wireless equipment for triple play broadband services using a single 2.5 GHz radio. IP Wireless suddenly looks like a strong candidate, going right up against WiMAX for Sprint Nextel and gives it a way of honoring the cable deal.

IP Wireless uses an implementation of time division duplexing, which creates a separate data channel in a cellular system, and has a TV variant of this which uses the 3GPP MBMS multicasting standard to make sure that any TV channel that is broadcast from a basestation, is only broadcast once.

Since Sprint Nextel merged and became aggressive about plans to build out its large holdings in 2.5GHz, it has been assumed that these plans would rest on WiMAX. It has had equipment trials with two pre-WiMAX vendors, Motorola and Samsung, and has development partnerships with Intel and other key 802.16 players.

Nextel has always had a trial going with IPWireless using the TD-CDMA standard, better known as TDD-UMTS and by making this week’s investment just as IP Wireless announces a TV system seems to run over TDD it spells out an alternative plan loud and clear. A defeat for WiMAX in this spectrum would be a huge blow and all the big guns will be pulling out all of the stops to ensure the IP Wireless deal doesn’t happen. This would in effect be a 3G UMTS technology operating in a spectrum that is strange to UMTS and mean lots of work and delay, and a service not before the end of 2007. But Mobile WiMAX would be at least this late anyway.

If this firms up as a decision it may be a blow to the WiMAX camp, but also to the Sprint incumbent technology supplier, Qualcomm.

Sprint Nextel recently poured cold water on speculation that it would create or lease a dedicated mobile TV network to complement its 3G offering, using either Qualcomm’s MediaFLO (chosen by Verizon Wireless) or the network being created by Crown Castle/Modeo across the US and supporting the DVB-H (Digital Video Broadcasting-Handheld) standard.

TD-CDMA is the time division duplex variant of the UMTS standard, which contrasts with the commonly used FDD version by supporting separate uplink and downlink. TDtv from IP Wireless combines TD-CDMA with MBMS

MBMS is a multicasting protocol that is coming out of 3GPP, whereby the cellular base stations are used to send the multicast TV signals, using the same radio to receive the TV signal as receives voice and other data services.

In DVB-H and all the other forms of mobile TV, a separate broadcast signal is sent in much lower frequency spectrum with better propagating properties and a far lower number of transmitters. But it still means someone building a second network.

A second radio is fitted to the handset and it blends to two data streams (see diagram below). This means that existing networks can be retrofitted with these services just by offering new handsets. TV services created in this way can be viewed on anything from a mobile handset to a PDA to specialist dedicated players and PCs.

MBMS is a unidirectional point to multipoint bearer service in which data is transmitted from a single source to multiple recipients. These services will typically be in the form of streaming video and audio and are a huge advance on the Cell Broadcast Service that is currently supported.

MBMS was always thought of as a software upgrade to UMTS base stations, due in UMTS release 6.0 and arriving in base stations in late 2007, and in handsets early in 2008. Handsets need to deal internally with multiple data feeds.

There is an equivalent, BroadCast MultiCast Services, or BCMCS for CDMA networks, but it appears that Sprint is moving off the Qualcomm dominated CDMA roadmap whichever option it takes.

The MBMS upgrade simply allows the logical process of a base station beginning to broadcast a TV channel the moment it has an request to do so from a handset, setting up a separate data channel for it.

Once that channel is being used for a TV program, any handset attached to the base station can pick up the same channel, being told where to look by the base station.

A broadcast group or multicast group can exist in all cells or just some, and opt ins are counted to determine what kind of channel is best, then a shared logical channel is set up. If there are no users in a given cell, it can hand back the channel and use the spectrum for voice.

The delivery is not quality of service guaranteed by the basic radio protocols, and there are no re-transmissions of packets, so if you get bad reception, that’s it. You have to rely on the underlying Forward Error Correction protocols to ensure you get most of any transmission. No-one’s tried it, so no one knows how well it would world in a real world situation.

To deliver Quarter VGA video at 30 frames per second, which is comparable with MediaFLO or DVB-H (or T-DMB or any other system) the bit rate needs to be something above 250 kbps, and is usually cited as 384 Kbps and can be as high as 450 Kbps. A 15 channel TV service, which is roughly what the other two mobile TV players are talking about, would need at last 5 Mbps perhaps more of dedicated bandwidth, which can be supported in multiple logical channels taking up perhaps 5MHz of bandwidth, according to IP Wireless. One problem with this (and almos any base station Mobile TV delivery network) is that base stations must all be equipped with sufficient backhaul delivery to offer 5 Mbps of data. Most existing networks won’t be built to that standard, but Sprint, as an operator of backhaul services across the US, could self provision a network of that capacity quite easily. Its competitors would have more trouble and so need to use a freshly built overlay network nd the datacasting technologies.

If poorer quality TV is OK, like the cellular delivered services which are currently delivered over 3G networks, at between 10 and 15 frames a second, and half the frame density, then something like 50 channels could be supported by the same system. However it is largely understood that TV services need to be QVGA or better to drive up take up and viewing figures.

Given that in many markets Sprint has 20 MHz of spectrum, it could probably afford even more TV channels and still have enough bandwidth to offer cellular voice over IP, along with music, internet access and other data services, all in a single integrated radio framework. But again, it might do this in either UMTS technologies or WiMAX

Sprint’s strategy will certainly let both Verizon and Modeo come to market a full year to 18 months before it can bring a service together. However Sprint chief operating officer Len Lauer told the WCA conference last week that he believes the use of the more powerful 2.5GHz network will push its mobile TV offering, when it arrives, ‘two years in advance of the other US carriers’.

A gradual shift of its existing CDMA customers to that service would leave it’s mobile operation fully 2.5GHz based.

Lauer said Sprint has not yet chosen the technology it will use, but the deal with IPWireless and the agreement to trial its new mobile TV technology, hard on the heels of his comments, paints a fairly strong picture.

Most European operators hold TDD spectrum that was allocated along with their 3G licenses, but few have used it because of past technical and bandwidth limitations. This is why IPWireless sees its main opportunities in Europe and Asia, where this spectrum is already held.

TD-CDMA is less threatening to cellcos than WiMAX because it is a technology that is still largely geared to the spectrum that they already hold.

IPWireless claims that the cost of adding MBMS to a handset will be only $10 by 2008, and that use of the 3GPP standard Broadcast Multicast Service Center (BMSC) ensures close integration with the main 3G services.

Sprint Nextel was always going to have the problem of building out too many networks, a replacement 3G network, one for mobile TV, and something in 2.5 such as WiMAX, and it looked all in all too expensive to do all three. If it adopts the IP Wireless route, it looks like it could do everything in one nationwide US network build.

Despite the inherent mobility of the TDD system, most of IP Wireless’ early build-outs have been for fixed or portable access, such as the UK Broadband system in the UK.

Sprint Nextel invested an initial $4m in IP Wireless last July and is currently trialing TD-CDMA technology in the Washington, DC area for broadband access for laptops, desktops or PDAs; backhaul for enterprise campus; and various interactive multimedia services such as video streaming, online gaming, document collaboration and videoconferencing.

IP Wireless says that several European carriers will follow in 1.9GHz 3G bands, likely to include T-Mobile, which is using TD-CDMA to support broadband data offerings. IPMobile also plans to trial TDtv in Japan using the 2.01 GHz spectrum it recently acquired, and in which TD-CDMA is specified.

Globally DVB-H remains the clear leader in mobile broadcasting technology with trials in some 26 countries, about 25% of which are gearing up for commercial launch in 2006.