A new draft of a proposed French law on copyright has had content owners up in arms this week, worried that it will effectively legalize file sharing in France.
The new proposal is set to limit the amount of copy protection that can be placed on recorded music, and cease to make it illegal for individuals to swap files, while still keeping those that offer masses of files, on the wrong side of the law.
In our view this is unlikely to make it into French law. The World Copyright Treaty has now been formed into a European Union directive that most European countries are putting onto their statute books. Norway recently amended its laws so that all the activity of DVD Jon would now be illegal. DVD Jon was the Norwegian boy who cracked CSS scrambling on DVDs and posted his method on websites all over the world. He also cracked the Fairplay DRM on Apple’s iPod. At the time he was immune from prosecution (although it was tried) because what he did was not illegal in Norway. Now it is.
This drift towards the thought processes that formed the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, is almost irreversible and the European Union could call France into line over amendments that went too far.
In fact this bill was created to enact that very same legislation but French consumer groups felt that making file sharing as bad a crime as counterfeiting, with prison sentences up to three years, and fines over $350,000, was taking things a bit too far. But introducing the idea of being allowed to interfere with copy protection is directly against the spirit of the treaty and if France break that, it would be in contravention of the directive.
Funnily enough in the US, where the US Patent and Trademark Office created the legislation, they are rethinking the law along the same lines. So perhaps the French instincts are more up to date than those who wrote the legislation.