Of all the barking mad rumors that Wall Street has thrown up around permanent acquirer Cisco, the idea that it might buy Nokia is maddest of all.
Nokia is the backbone of Finland and inscrutable in its ways and means, and from the financial perspective alone it is worth two thirds of what Cisco is worth and it’s just too big a deal to swallow.
But also from a product consolidation point of view Nokia makes devices and cellular phones which do not, as a rule, use the internet protocol. They might one day, as WiMAX begins to have some influence, but for the time being Nokia would be a brand new business in a margin squeezed world. It makes more sense to buy Motorola than Nokia, because it’s cheaper, it’s American and it’s in the same business. And no it shouldn’t do that either.
What Cisco wants is to wring every last drop of revenue out of the internet protocol. It justifies getting into consumer electronics because they will, in future, have an internet element. It can justify getting into core networks where there are IP, and IP switches, by buying the far cheaper Nortel and turning its finances and credibility around.
It can also buy into WiMAX at a decent level and take the IP protocol into the airwaves.
But it’s make no sense for it to consider buying the largest employer in Finland, from shareholders that are almost exclusively Finnish, to get into businesses it neither wants or understands. We put in the usual caveat that insane mergers are sometimes conducted by insane people, so never say never. And Cisco may well bid for, and potentially capture Nokia networks under the right conditions, but we suspect not.