Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 February 2006

Top 100 films falling in revenues, fewer making it big in 2005

If the top 100 films, measured by revenues, are anything to go on, the cinema industry is heading more and more deeply into a crisis.

Counts are now available for the revenue brought in by the top 100 films and UK research house Screen Digest has added some of its own numbers and done some analysis that suggests they took far less money than those issued in the previous three years with only one blockbuster film, the latest Star Wars movie, taking more than $300 million in 2005, compared to at least three in previous years.

In total the top ten films accounted for just 23.6 % of total market revenues, and only 53 films brought in $100m during 2005 compared to 65 films in 2004.

We asked head of Cinema research at Screen Digest David Hancock, what his take was on the recent numbers, ‘In general the total box office for films for 2005 is down. There are 5 territories, China, Russia, Malaysia, Korea and the UK where it’s up. But it’s only up in the UK by 1%. The other 13 territories we have figures for so far show that box office is down. This includes a drop of 4% in the US, with the largest drop being Poland, where cinema attendance is off by 26.7%.’

‘Eastern Europe is always a difficult one to call, the number of screens is going up, but not as fast as it was a few years ago, but also there are very few people that can afford to go to the cinema in these countries and we have low admissions per head.’

But Hancock refuses to see the inevitable demise of the cinema as an outcome. ‘We’ve had situations before, like in the 1980s, when DVDs came on the scene, so new media expanded. Cinema exhibitors have always managed to position themselves, on that occasion using big sound, and bigger screens to increase the experience gap between the home and the cinema.

‘Now we have a move to digital distribution and I think there will still be a place for the cinema. Digital cinemas reduce the cost of distribution and that could lead to more films being shown at any given cinema and a rise in the total revenue per screen.’

Hancock also talks about the experiments with releases in DVD, theaters (cinemas) online and cable VoD all at once. ‘Some films that might struggle in theaters, perhaps because they are not for a tightly defined audience, may do better with an across the board release,’ he argues.

But for our money the opposite applies. In essence the shape of the market is changing subtly. More advertising is spent, on fewer films to create fewer blockbusters. Spreading the release over a wider audience and multiple formats initially at least plays to those companies that can afford to experiment. And if there are viable formats that cost less than cinema, such as online, why not release films online only, at very low risk.

The outcome is potentially a disastrous one for the exhibitors, the cinema owners, although it may be fine for both large studios and independents alike, who may use online in particular to bypass the exiting distribution chain.

One interesting fact that Hancock points out is that there were a record 293,835 physical prints made for the top 100 films, substantially higher than in previous years, which means that revenue per print is falling.

As cinema complexes are still being built out in the Far East, and elsewhere single screen theaters are still being replaced with multiplexes, it means that more and more screens are coming online. But as the average revenue for each one of those screens fall, it puts pressure on the viability of cinema owners.

First off, the control that the top distributors have on cinema seats will falter. At present it’s an easy choice. Take the top distributor’s films because they are going to make more money for you. This is slowly ceasing to be true.

There are enough films distributed from the top five studio chains that they take up much of the available viewing time throughout the year at global cinemas, roughly 75% to 80%. There is little room for local and independent material, and independent film makers are driven to Hollywood for distribution deals which are very much written in Hollywood’s favor, but which at least give some return on an investment for independents.

But if the big studios and their distribution arms cannot guarantee any more success with their list of films than independent distributors, then their control over global cinema chains will begin to wane. Screen Digest also shows that more and more revenue is delivered in the opening weekends of the bigger films. This exacerbates the problem, meaning that cinemas can take the top films, guarantee them a home for less time, squeeze most of the revenue out of them in their first week, but then move on to other film releases more rapidly. This supports Hancock’s view of there eventually being more films in the market.

In 2005, the first weekend of all the films accounted for an average 29 % of box office per movie in the top 100 films against 27.4 % in 2003.

More of this will lead to a speeding up of the film cycle, with bigger and bigger hits, issued more widely, in shorter and shorter time spans, and with more cinemas competing with each others using the same top films. No cinema can afford to continue showing a film while its neighbors and competitors have already moved on to the next release.

The fact that more money is coming in on the opening weekends almost certainly points to those films with the higher advertising and promotional spend taking off, but then falling away either because the films don’t get recommended or because viewers feel that it will soon be available to view in their living rooms, under their own control, on increasingly large and high resolution TVs.

Screen Digest tells us that last year the top 10 films grossed an average of $57,721 per screen, 20 % lower than in 2004. That 20% comes straight out of the pocket of the exhibitors. Revenue per print has been falling since 2003 among the top 100 films.

The leading distributor inside the top 100 in 2005 was Fox with $1.34bn from 14 films, and the highest revenue per release of $95.6m.Warner was the second best performer, grossing $1bn from 13 releases in the top 100.

DreamWorks showed that it could go out to a wider audience with Madagascar going out to 4,142 cinemas at release, the only movie to go to over 4,000 engagements in 2005. But while wider distribution works for the film studios to stop revenues falling, lower revenue per screen is a daunting prospect for the cinema owners.

Faultline has been saying for the past three years that the trend in cinema value and revenue will be inevitably down, and will lead to a point in a few years time when it is impossible for the average cinema group to make as much money as they would get for selling the real estate the theater is built on. We know Screen Digest doesn’t agree, but if you factor in the movement away from TV viewing towards DVD, online films, DVRs, and web archives like Google Video, plus the rise and rise of game play, we see leisure time drifting inevitably away from lengthy time consuming cinema visits.