Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 February 2006

French piracy case just one instance, DMCA directive still stands

Multiple sources of news this week have reported the French case of where it appears one court has said that file sharing is okay for personal use in France and the other case a week or so ago where French law makers were inclined to tamper with the new copyright law so as to make it less effective.

Everyone is behaving as if the two are linked and they’re not. The most recent case is an individual case involving one person that had a lot of copyrighted files on their computer. There are two different versions of this and we’ve not been able to get to the bottom of this quite yet, with one suggesting he was okay because he was just using these files for himself, and another version saying these were detected as available for download, and yet he still got off because it was not for commercial gain. This is a tricky part of the law as it is currently written in many parts of Europe, which is the entire point of US pressure to get these laws to change.

We think that the downloading aspect is key here. No-one in the US has been fined or pursued simply for downloading, only for offering files for copying. The French are definitively going to opt for an interpretation of the law which defends the individual’s rights. This is a very French thing and a good thing, but no French judge is going to change the copyright law that is enforced by a Europe wide copyright directive based on the World Copyright Treaty, itself based on the Digital Millenium Copyright Act.

French lawmakers have every right to discuss the precise shape of their own version of the new copyright law, but will, in the end, be unable to deviate too far from the core directives. However the French version of the law could easily be on the lenient side of the directive. The same is likely to occur in the Netherlands and Scandinavian countries, but the entire change is around making it illegal to tamper with copy protection, and that is unlikely to be removed anywhere.

If French lawmakers try to kick these key aspects out, then they have to go through the European Commission, which will have to take it back to the World Copyright Treaty for a rethink, which would be no bad thing. Most European countries are deliberately years late enacting this law change because it is a vote losers and they don’t like it.