It’s hard to review the oceans of detailed documents that have been produced by and for Leonardo Chiariglione and Thomas Curran, the two digital media technical wizards behind the Digital Media Project (DMP), but there are a new set, which takes the organization closer to its expressed intent of producing interoperable Digital Rights Management.
The new document IDP-2, looks extremely similar, as its predecessor IDP-1 was before it, to MPEG 21 documents. MPEG 21 is the still standing committee that has not been mentioned in print for the past two years, that was supposed to be standardizing DRM and communication between different DRMs.
The documents produced by Chiariglione appear impenetrable, but at the same time also appear pointless. In them the Telecom Italia employed pioneer that brought us MPEG 2, describes DRMs as if they WILL be written in the future to his spec, which have to show they have certain properties, such as declaring their activities to each other and handing over content keys.
This approach seems to be a little na’ve given that most DRM systems neither trust, nor want to trust another, albeit proven, compliant piece of software. And the companies that own DRM pieces of software see DRM interoperability as best achieved by dominating the market and forcing everyone to use their DRM.
If Chiariglione manages to complete this gargantuan piece of DRM definition work, it may well be that without Microsoft, Apple and Sony and Philip’s Intertrust on board, it will be a standard which never gets implemented.
The IDP-2 specification has been approved and will be released and published in April 2006. IDP-2 purports to allow an open framework which allows users to mix up either standard or proprietary DRM technologies, while still retaining digital media interoperability.
The first spec, out last Spring, a year after the organization had formed, was called IDP-1 and uses the content identification schemes worked out in MPEG-21 and incorporates a rights expression language which is an extended subset of the ISO MPEG REL based on ContentGuard’s XrML work.
It was also based around public key infrastructure, using the 128-bit AES encryption standard, X.509 digital certificates, and XML.
While we are not sure it will ever be used in anger, we are sure that Chiariglione will grind on and on until the opus is complete. The companies supporting him and the Digital Media Project include British Telecom, Telecom Italia, the BBC, a few learned institutes, in Europe, China, Germany and Japan, DivX, Panasonic, Mitsubishi Electric and consulting group BearingPoint. No top content owners or broadcasters in sight apart from the BBC.