The New York Times was tempted into a warning shot at the momentum behind the Sony led Blu-ray high definition DVD camp this week, citing rumors of delays and expense that could potentially derail Sony’s Play Station 3 launch. A Blu-ray player is expected to come bundled in the PS3 when it arrives later this year, and the notion that if one is delayed, so must the other, is pushed hard in this piece.
But the piece came together after interviewing a senior Microsoft executive who said things like “We were getting a lot of data saying the HD-DVD format was a walk in the park and Blu-ray was having trouble.’ This was an attempt to justify Microsoft’s decision to back the Toshiba led HD DVD, and comes from a software company that has never built hardware, up against the 150 or so consumer electronics firms that back Blu-ray and which have built about 90% of the worlds consumer electronics equipment, including Panasonic, Samsung Philips and Sony itself.
Naturally the New York Times gave pride of place to the Microsoft version of events, otherwise it wouldn’t have had a story.
The idea for any kind of story on Blu-ray was stimulated earlier in the week by a report from Merrill Lynch which suggested that the PS3 could only be made for $900, and that if it came out at $500 retail in order to undercut Toshiba HD players, it would cost Sony a fortune in subsidy and also hurt its Blu-ray partners. However you look at this Merrill’s believes that Sony can’t win.
We’re not sure how much work went into the valuation of $900, but we would remind readers that the Sony PSP was going to cost at least $500 to make and could not come out below $500 at retail. It hit the market at $180 in Japan and $190 in the US and it is showing as a huge boon to Sony figures.
The same company (Merrill Lynch) said in July last year that the Sony PS3 would cost $494 per console (perhaps that’s without the Blu-ray player in it, but they never said that), but said it would retail in the US for $399, with some of that going to the retail partner.
Now it says they will cost it $900 and only retail for $299, in order to compete with the Xbox 360. Sony has always priced significantly above the Microsoft Xbox and squeezed it on margin by sitting above it, and the PS3 is so significantly more powerful than the Xbox, it will do this again.
Given that there is no way of knowing what the cost of the core Cell processing component is (IBM is only making them for Sony right now and then Sony makes its own), there really is no way of solidifying these figures.
Sony initially responded by saying that Toshiba is missing the point over Blu-ray players, because the first people who buy new technologies don’t care that it is more expensive, they just want the technology first.
Then Sony issued a statement that it would begin shifting Blu-ray DVD titles on May 23 and a Sony branded player shortly after that.
Sony and MGM will initially release eight titles including 50 First Dates, The Fifth Element, Hitch, and House of Flying Daggers. Samsung will put its player on the market on the same day.
Independent studio Lions Gate, also said it would release 10 titles on the same day, including Crash and Lord of War, The Punisher, Saw and Terminator 2: Judgment Day, A second wave of titles will follow shortly thereafter in June or July including Reservoir Dogs, Total Recall, Stargate and Dune.
Toshiba replied that it would have about 40 movie titles out by then including Batman Begins, Sahara and Jarhead.
For over a year now we have been consistently pointing out that the war has been won some time ago by Blu-ray and however anyone dresses it up, Microsoft and Intel have virtually no bearing on the case and the New York Times should be more careful about the objectivity of its coverage. It doesn’t want to be accused of only listening to US companies.