Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

TiVo may give away its DVRs – What’s new?

TiVo finds itself without a mother ship these days, having lost the DirecTV account and failing to land Comcast after coming so close. Now the company is thinking about giving its DVRs away in order to sell its $13-a-month subscription and other services. At least that’s what TiVo CEO Tom Rogers told the Reuters Global Technology, Media and Telecoms Summit in New York this week.

That’s no surprise considering that DirecTV also gave away most of the TiVo-based DVRs that it “sold.”

Rogers said the company was considering a range of pricing options, including one plan that would include a free set-top box. “We’re continuing to pursue the prospects of zero upfront and all upfront pricing, Rogers said. To get the free box, consumers would have to sign up for higher-priced and longer-term plans – similar to the way mobile operators work subsidizing handsets.

DirecTV sold the majority of the TiVo boxes that are in use, making the loss of the account a major blow to TiVo’s ability to grow its user base.
What’s bad for TiVo is good for NDS. Last year DirecTV said that it would switch to using boxes based on technology from NDS, a sister company to DirecTV. Humax makes the NDS boxes and Thomson, which made a lot of the TiVo-based DVRs for DirecTV, is expected to make some too. DirecTV said some months ago that it was not placing any new orders for TiVo-based boxes. It is not certain whether that is still true.

Rumors were that at one point TiVo walked away from a deal with Comcast, the world’s largest cable TV service. It later managed to salvage part of the deal by getting Comcast to agree to embed the TiVo software in future DVRs made by Motorola. Doing so will enable Comcast subscribers to access the TiVo electronic program guide by paying a premium over and above the usual subscription fee.

At this point, and for the foreseeable future, it’s the pay-TV services like DirecTV and Comcast that will control the market for DVRs. DVR makers like TiVo have several hurdles when it comes to selling directly to pay-TV subscribers:

– They can’t integrate with the channel tuners like the pay-TV services can.
– They don’t have direct access to the subscribers.
– Pay-TV services can afford to offer DVRs at low monthly rates, even give them away.
– Because the satellite TV services don’t have true video-on-demand, only pay-per-view, they must sell DVRs to compete with the cablecos.

TiVo will also have to compete with non-pay-TV-sponsored DVRs. The most important of those is likely to be PCs based on Microsoft’s Windows Media Center technology. DirecTV has already done a deal with Microsoft to make Media Center PCs capable of serving as DirecTV receivers.

Rogers, who became CEO of TiVo last July, said the company is likely to start testing new pricing plans relatively soon. Here’s betting the company has no other choice if it wants to expand its customer base.