Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

Audio flag bill has been introduced to Congress

We knew that an ‘audio’ flag bill was coming in the US and now it has been introduced by Congressman Mike Ferguson as a House Resolution called ‘The audio broadcast licensing act of 2006.’ Of course that doesn’t make it law and it has a long way to go, and many opponents.

This is really the Recording Industry Association of America jumping on a broadcasting bandwagon started by the Motion Picture Association of America. The MPAA over the past few years lobbied successfully to get the US Federal Communications Commission to insist that manufacturers of TV sets put in the ability to recognize and refuse copying on broadcasts which contained a special key. This was subsequently killed by court action with a US court telling the FCC that it was operating outside of its mandate, and that effectively it had created a new law.

So at the tail end of 2005 Congress began looking to introduce such a law on the FCC’s behalf, and the RIAA thought ‘What a good idea,’ let’s have one for audio.

Ferguson has now introduced legislation that if enacted would stop any digital audio player, for instance satellite radio players, and DAB service receivers and web radio, from being stored if they contain a broadcast audio flag.

What’s stupid about this law is that first all of the satellite radio equipment suppliers already offer storage and copying functions, so it would harm these services and their investors immeasurably, and also the idea is not to introduce a strong DRM, but just a flag that relies on the player to agree not allow copying. Such a system is easily bypassed by pirates.

It also, just like the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, treads all over US laws that say that consumers have a right to make a personal copy of content. We would expect this bill to have a rocky ride making it into law.