The consolidation of the Flash memory business was always going to see Lexar Media acquired at some point, but last week’s deal whereby it goes to Micron for around $666 million looks like a rapid strengthening of the Micron Intel axis in Flash memory, injecting it with some key intellectual property.
Lexar is probably more valuable in intellectual property than it is as a going concern. It is one of the leaders in intellectual property regarding Flash memory controllers. All of the Lexar patents relate to programmable controllers that increase write speeds and reduce overhead, using what it describes as a proprietary, indirect mapping methodology.
The deal was cut for what amounts to just 7% of the Micron equity and was likely triggered by a court decision in December to grant Toshiba a new trial for its supposed misappropriation of trade secrets from Lexar.
Lexar had been awarded $465 million, with potentially more to come, by the Santa Clara County Superior Court after a jury trial. This amounted to some 68% of one year’s revenues for Lexar at a stroke. Interestingly Toshiba holds some 50,000 patents, home and abroad, with something like 5,750 of them relating to flash memory and other semiconductor technologies, while Lexar held just 72 at the time of the trial and claims just 94 patents and patent applications even now.
The trial was a strange one that somehow went wrong for Toshiba. It had helped to get Lexar off the ground with investment and access to its own engineers. Then suddenly both companies were filing patent infringements suits against each other. The US jury perhaps didn’t quite get the full story and while most people believe that this was a monster multinational cheating on a group of innocent fresh faced engineers, there is an argument that this was a bunch of US chancers taking the na’ve Japanese chip maker to the cleaners.
The jury verdict will not be challenged in the re-trial, so Toshiba will remain guilty on the books, of stealing Lexar secrets, a conclusion reached through an email paper trail in several languages. What will be rethought is the extent of the damages, so suddenly Lexar couldn’t look forward to $465 million in its bank any time soon, and its ailing finances forced it onto the market.
The court case will either drag on after the deal, and every Flash memory maker learns to live with constant patent litigation, or it will get quietly settled for a much lower figure, rather than risk another court dropping it to almost zero. Toshiba has been promising to fight it no matter how much it is and swears that the jury made a mistake and were wrongly led and wants an appeal when it can challenge the verdict, as well as this retrial to lower the payment.
Lexar’s past has been littered with legal actions and a recent filing from SanDisk, Fuji Photo Film, Eastman Kodak, Memorex Products, PNY Technologies and Verbatim accused the company of false and misleading claims for its controller technology. This case has yet to come to court.
But strangely this deal is not about Micron suddenly getting into Flash. No, the strangest thing is that Micron has only just got out of Flash. Filings made in February showed that it had actually sold its existing NAND flash memory technology and chip designs to Intel for $270 million. This was done as part of the deal for Micron and Intel setting up in business as IM Flash Technologies LLC a new manufacturing joint venture.
Micron kept a license for it to use the designs but the NAND flash memories that the joint venture will make are now designs that belong to Intel. It could be that Micron is buying itself yet another seat at the flash memory table with the Lexar intellectual property, or that it will contribute it, instead of cash, to the joint venture.
The original deal formed a company, owned 51% by Micron and 49% by Intel which would make flash chips for both companies. At the same time both companies landed a chunk of the Apple ongoing business for Flash memory, mostly used in its iPods.
Each agreed to contribute $1.2 billion in either cash or assets up front and a further $1.4 billion each over the next three years.
Apple prepaid around $250 million each to Intel and Micron and also cut similar deals with Hynix, Samsung and Toshiba. Samsung also happens to be a licensee of the Lexar patents.
At the time, that deal with Micron seemed to be a way for Intel to sidestep out of its predominantly NOR flash business and add NAND flash designs at a stroke. If you add the Lexar patents to the pile, it could be close to catching up with Samsung and Toshiba, the global leaders in NAND flash.
NAND flash is cheaper to make than NOR flash and is best used on sequential file delivery like large video or music files. Until the Micron deal, Intel was not producing NAND flash, but supplies NOR flash, mostly into the mobile phone market. That makes this deal an entr’e for Intel to get into the business against arch rival Samsung. This is especially important as NAND flash will be used more and more in the mobile market, as larger entertainment files are stored on mobiles.
The purchase of Lexar is subject to regulatory review, Lexar stockholder approval and other customary closing conditions and already the Lexar market capitalization has risen from $548 million to $710 million. This doesn’t really mean that investors think it will go for more than the agreed price, or that another company will come in for it, but that the Micron share price, which fell by $1 billion to $9 billion on the announcement of the deal, might recover. The deal is pegged to the Micron share price and if it recovers fully before the deal is complete, this would make the price for Lexar above its current $710 million value, closer to $740 million.