As the ink dries on the first round of commentary on the Bellsouth AT&T merger, it occurs to us that very few people have given much thought to what happens if IPTV is a complete failure in the heartland of America. A failure that stretches the length and breadth of AT&T as well as Bellsouth will make twice as much noise.
What messages will it send out, what consequences will there be for the antagonists, and what will be the results in terms of share price and investment feelings towards those that fail? Also what would failure look like, and what types of competing services could stop the RBOC juggernaut.
Well we are finally seeing content companies doing deals with online delivery companies, so content is already going to be available to download and do anything that you want with.
We already know of services which allow download to a DVR, download to burn and download to rent and unlimited downloads for a subscription. This will cause an enormous amount of what we call ‘TV augmentation.’
These services include those announced by Starz, Apple, Google, Sony Clear Channel, 4Flix, Blinkx, AOL, Arvato, LoveFilm, BSkyB, NTL and DirecTV, plus the rumor that Amazon is about to conclude a deal to offer its own service later this year, as are Blockbuster and NetFlix
Even Microsoft with its Origami PC has got into the act with a deal with Movielink and of course services like Akimbo, the original download to DVR service in the US, is beginning to pick up valuable content for the first time.
Anything that augments TV in this way will slow down the rate at which true TV ‘Replacement’ services are accepted.
Mobile TV will hit the US in a big way during 2006 with launches at both Verizon, built around a deal with Qualcomm and its MediaFLO technology, and at Modeo, which has yet to announced a cellular partner, but which is ready to hit the top 30 US markets any time now.
The quality of mobile TV pictures is going to surprise many and again act as an inhibitor to Telco TV take up, at the same time as acting as another drain on available advertising revenues.
So while it may be true that once a household has bought into a triple play, it will find it hard to leave, so that churn reduction is effected, if the absolute numbers taking up the service are not large enough, low churn will comfort nobody.
We know that to really foster churn reduction, IPTV has to offer services which integrate together, for instance a telephone service that can put information about calls on your TV screen or which interacts with your PC held data.
And many of these types of service integrations are further down the technology roadmap than most people believe, heading off into 2008 and beyond.
Hybrids also have the potential to dent take up rates. So a TV service using MVDDS line of sight spectrum (re-using the satellite spectrum in 12.2 GHz), which also gives wonderfully fast asymmetric html downloads, with perhaps a WiMAX or Powerline return path, would absolutely kill IPTV in a given area. We know of a few installations like this which are going to be rolled out in tiny 16 mile across regions in the US, which will offer 200 Standard Definition TV channels and 70 High Definition channels, plus VoD, plus blazing file downloads. MVDDS innovator MDS America just bought up the remainder of this spectrum in a December FCC auction, while in earlier auctions Cablevision and EchoStar bought much of the available spectrum. Between the three of them they could cover the US.
In Europe DVB-T combined with a much slower return path, perhaps 1 to 2 Mbps of best effort broadband, can offer a VoD service merged at the set top with a 30 to 60 channel broadcast. British Telecom is famous for planning a service with this, while the rest of Europe is perhaps a few months behind in offering such services so they may arrive in 2007. The US free to air broadcasters could just as easily enter the fray here using either DVB-T, which is not generally favored in the US, but an ATSC version of this, operated in a hybrid with a best effort return path, could make developments at IPTV companies harder. So there will be localized viable broadcast competition.
This is because hybrids can cost less. An MVDDS (Multichannel Video Distribution and Data Service) license might cost $9 million for a single city, and a transmitter may cost $250,000 to buy, and it may need a 300 foot tower to work from, but after that there are very few continuing costs, and the system can run for decades. The same can be said of ATSC hybrids, and in many cases the spectrum is already held by local broadcasters and just needs a best effort return path which cab be provided by the RBOCs themselves or by their competitors.
And there is always the prospect of cable TV operators both going through further mergers and consolidation and getting their costs down substantially, and savagely cutting their prices. A cable operator with more buying power ends up spending less on content, not more, because of the increased negotiating power.
Cable operators have felt no downward price pressure as yet from IPTV, but once that comes and is witnessed in the market, they have the power to stop the erosion right in its tracks.
There are various forecasts for IPTV take up, and virtually none of them factor in any drag from these competing, augmenting and hybrid options. At Faultline we are predicting a pretty grim time for all TV services, as too many services create too many service tiers, and both subscription and advertising revenues are shared across all of them.
This will mean that there’s plenty of content, in plenty of formats, and that slightly more TV will be consumed than is consumed today, but that each individual approach to TV will have to survive with less of the pie.
But even taking a recent TDG prediction for IPTV hitting 37.8 million subscribers worldwide by 2010, that would likely mean that around 16 million of those are in the US, and assuming a roughly even split across the three major RBOCs, that would mean that AT&T’s take, when merged with Bellsouth, would need to be just over 10 million in 4 years.
That’s an annual additional revenue of something like $3.5 billion assuming a price substantially under cable operator pricing today, and probably, over time, that kind of penetration might give it a payback on its investment, mostly in reduced telephone subscriber churn.
Over the last two years AT&T and Bellsouth have been selling TV services for EchoStar and DirecTV respectively, but during they time they haven’t managed to sell even 1 million customers between them. So we’re not quite sure just how they will fare when they’re required to sell a new system at something like 4 times that rate, during a period of increased competition and more and better video offerings. DirecTV itself will be offering hundreds of High Definition channels in competition, as is the EchoStar Dish Network.
So if we see the new merged entity putting on less than 1 million new subscribers during its first general release year of IPTV, it must be considered a failure and the IPTV forecast numbers, for the US at least, must be considered out of reach. Keep that number in mind.