There are two distinct legal decisions going on in France relating to digital media, and they are virtually contradictory. The first is that France is going through the process of enacting the World Copyright Treaty (WCT), which is based around the Digital Millenium Copyright Act. The second is altogether something more sinister and relates to outlawing software lock-ins.
Funnily enough most of the scare stores coming out of France have all been about legalizing P2P downloading. These stories come from the process by which a local flavor is put into the WCT and how the legal wording will go in the French version of the law. This is now more or less over and very little untoward has happened.
Every European country is virtually press-ganged into implementing the WCT by the European Commission. This is the legislation that includes the onerous issue of citizens never interfering with content protection, even where this goes against local laws that say that content buyers are allowed to make personal copies of their purchased works.
So during the past 4 weeks or so you can ignore all of the scary news headlines that relate to the French legalizing P2P file downloading. In the end French politicians have made sure that the wording of the law are more or less in line with the aims of the DMCA.
The dominant political party in France won the day and out went amendments that offered to legalize internet downloading and instead replace it with a tax of around $15 a month that would form an artistes’ royalty pool.
That solution was fraught with problems. First off it would have meant being in breach of its EU responsibilities and its signature of the WCT, secondly it would have made France a haven for organizing downloading activity for the rest of the world and finally it would have meant the creation of an unfair taxation that would have to be distributed to the richer companies and which would not have made artistes any richer.
The European Commission, as we have said on many previous occasions would not brook tampering with that law. In fact in the end the French went further and clarified its own position with new elements in its copyright bill introducing longer prison terms and larger fines.
But the second legal move by the French does give cause for concern, or at least some thought. What they are trying to do is to outlaw a DRM lock in. In simple terms Apple would have to make it possible to use iTunes downloads on devices other than an iPod.
This will have been inspired as much by local ownership of among other companies Archos, a French portable device maker, which is one of the few companies that use Microsoft Windows DRM on a non-Windows platform. Archos offers portable video and music players.
Apple can’t be got at under exiting law, because while it has a virtual monopoly on online music sales, there are other places to buy the same songs online, and online makes up such a small part of the music market.
Apple can’t be forced into this under the new Copyright Bill, because that says quite clearly that content protections must be left alone. So it needed to enact a new law.
The French logic is that it doesn’t want its citizens forced into high prices by any kind of lock-in where users cannot interfere with the content protection, so it thinks it can mandate DRM interoperability.
This is clearly anti Apple. Once Apple allows any kind of DRM interoperability so that iPod music can be copied legally to another architecture, it loses its control of the iPod market, and in effect everyone can make iPods, or devices that can be interchanged with them.
Such a move would wipe out Apple’s share price overnight and it’s unlikely that Apple will allow it.
Competitors like those companies using Microsoft Windows DRM and other MP3 player makers (some of which use no copy protection) will need to offer a protection that could handshake with Apple’s Fairplay and they would all opt for Microsoft’s Windows Media DRM, because that’s easy to do and to license, creating a Microsoft monopoly where previously there wasn’t one. Which really isn’t helpful.
It is a farcical decision, and one that will be taxing minds over at Apple. So far it has come up with the idea of closing iTunes France and shutting everyone out of the iPod market there. At least then a local law wouldn’t have a global affect.
In the end Apple probably knows that it needs to offer interoperability between Fairplay and selected other DRMs. It is easy for anyone working with Microsoft DRM to offer interoperability, because Microsoft is not operating the final system. A Microsoft system can run side by side with another DRM, as it does on mobile handsets under the CoreMedia version of the OMA DRM standard which works with Windows Media DRM.
Since it can offer this to mobile operators and it is they who issue the encryption keys and set key handling rules, they can allow a key to be issued to either the OMA DRM or the Windows DRM, whichever the handset is running.
But since Apple is also the operator of the Fairplay DRM in iTunes, no-one else can legally get involved in managing keys.
If the French law is passed there are a number of other interesting aspects that will emerge. Those companies that continue to operate in France, even if Apple pulls out, must build a method of interoperability, which will automatically be exported outside of France (Apple could alternatively offer an interoperable DRM in France, different from its famous Fairplay system).
And the new French law would have to be couched in very careful terms. Would it apply to encryption keys used in smart cards for financial transactions and in mobile handsets and in TV conditional access systems. Our thought is that it would.
So NDS would have to allow its TV content to be copyable not just to a portable device with an NDS SVP processor in it, but also to an iPod or other portable device.
We imagine that financial transactions security would be significantly weakened by any form of key interoperability and this is likely to be allowed an exception, but not conditional access.
Once this is realized, other forces will move into play. France Telecom would have an expensive refit of all of its IPTV and cable TV set tops; new IPTV players would be forced into stalling their plans, and other multinational players like Nagravision would incur huge costs.
Because of this there will either need to be very specific wording, so that this is making a law to govern Apple, and then it would have cause for serious complaint to the EU, or it would need to be very carefully thought out over a period of potentially years, and consultations issued globally to ascertain the costs and the effects. My guess is that this will get pointed out and the legislation will just get bogged down in red tape and disappear into a dusty Brussels backroom (European Union HQ).