Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 March 2006

UWB Focus group totally gets Wireless USB, worries about security

Staccato Communications has just released a set of focus group findings on the subject of Ultra Wide Band and the potential for it to act as a carrier for wireless USB. Key findings were that consumers love the concept, worry a little about security and can come up with lots and lots of ways in which they would like to see it used.

Staccato Communications did the focus groups as part of its ‘UWB University’ initiative and will give webinars on the findings later this week.

It took university students that had experience of PCs, wi-fi and MP3 players and explained what Wireless USB and UWB will do when it is launched, hopefully late in 2006, and then asked questions on what the students thought.

The result was what Staccato described as ‘extraordinary excitement’ for the value proposition for Wireless USB in the sense of it removing cables completely from PCs and peripherals. The focus group had an immediate and intuitive understanding of what functions Wireless USB would offer, based on USB brand recognition. However past user experiences soured the focus group thinking about a UWB replacement for BlueTooth, with virtually no-one having a good word to say about the short range communications technology.

New use cases emerged from the two hour long discussions, including Peer-to-peer applications not currently served by wired USB, such as iPod to iPod, iPod to speakers in both the car and the home, Video iPod connections to TV and digital camera communication with other digital cameras.

When the Focus Group then went on to examine perceived problems there were concerns about security and a lack of understanding about range and power of the signal. This seems to suggest that wireless USB needs to be sold with a strong security message and clear guidelines for what it will and will not do. Many of the focus group just assumed it would work over wi-fi distances and failed to understand why it wouldn’t.

Another concern was about being first to buy devices with Wireless USB in, with group members worried that these might not work with older devices, and this suggested that a retrofit market of add-ons for older devices, to make them USB ready, will be an important, if temporary, market, especially given that there is an installed base of 2.5 billion USB units.

Most of industry has already understood these use cases and limitations and a couple of weeks ago, when we were talking to Texas Instruments it clearly understood the use case of driving a full TV screen from a mobile device, but felt that mobile handsets would not be ready for that until battery use of UWB devices came down.

Ultra Wide Band works under the noise floor of existing radio technologies but uses a broad range of spectrum, sending in parallel. It is capable of sending signals at between 480 Mbps and 1 Gbps in its current implementations. While the FCC has licensed UWB in the US, other regulators are working hard to bring European, Japanese and Chinese regulations into line in time for wide availability of the technology. There are three major flavors of the technology, one pushed by pioneer Pulse~Link which invented the concept, one by Freescale and the most powerful body politically is headed up by Intel and Texas Instruments called the WiMedia Alliance.

Given that the speed of a UWB chip communicates as fast as the internal bus on a PC, we think that all electronics devices will change dramatically. For instance a PC could be built with a portable component the size of an iPod, which included both the storage and processor elements and this could talk to any screen or peripheral while sitting inside a pocket. The same device could be used as your work PC, your MP3 player, your laptop and your home PC, coupled with both home and work automated backup through UWB connections. The technology will eventually, in the 2008 time frame, turn mobile handsets into portable digital video recorders.