It has to be said that the GSM Association’s protestations over potentially heavy handed treatment by the European Commission over roaming charges, are a case of too little, too late. The EC has called for the mobile industry to police itself for years and its patience was bound to grow thin eventually.
What the GSMA said in a statement in London this week was that extra regulation is unnecessary and that it could do long-term damage to a key European industry. Sure it could deny it constant windfall profits.
The GSMA issued a formal response to the European Commission’s proposals, pointing out that mobile operators offer roaming services as part of a package of interrelated services, which it says offer very good value for consumers. Mobile prices have fallen at an average of 5% per annum over the past four years the statement said.
But tell that to someone that makes three phones calls in another country and ends up with a bill of $200 when their usual monthly charge is $50.
Just three weeks ago European Information Society commissioner, Vivian Reding, said she would rush through legislation in time for 2007 saying that mobile operators had ignored multiple warnings and roaming fees were unjustifiably high.
The EC had found instances of a roaming charges as high as $15 a minute, and Reding suggested that at some point in the future roaming charges should be abolished altogether.
Roaming charges are after all a simple export of internet packets across a boarder, usually shipped over fast fiber, plus a few software provisions at the base station. The GSM Association says that roaming charges have fallen by an 8% average across Europe, but when the roaming charges costs 10 times more than the call, then something is wrong with the system.
The other objections the GSMA raised was that regulation would have unforeseen consequences and said competition is the best way to regulate services. But actually users cannot opt for a different ‘roaming’ carrier if their operator has not set up a roaming relationship in the first place. So actually there is no competition here.
Finally the GSMA wants to slow the whole process down and get a full impact assessment, presumably one that takes years to complete, rather than introduce hastily constructed legislation.
‘From the limited information publicly available, the European Commission’s proposals appear to be based on an outdated and incomplete view of the roaming market and the wider mobile industry,’ said Rob Conway, CEO and board member of GSMA. ‘Before taking the drastic step of bypassing the existing regulatory framework, the Commission needs to undertake a careful analysis of the fast-changing European mobile market and the potential impact of any further legislation.’ God forbid it make calls cheaper.