Hollywood has finally caved in and made the announcement that films can go to online download on demand (DoD) delivery as soon as they go on DVD release. The news came through the studios jointly owned Movielink distribution service, but this announcement is considerably more far reaching that the bland announcement suggests.
With a lot of noise and celebration Movielink said it would launch the first US download-to-own film service with films that come out the same time as they go to DVD. Previously Movielink has only ever offered download to rent films. These films are only available in the US, and we would expect similar initiatives to be made outside the US as licensing negotiations permit.
The first thing to say about this it that it is not the FIRST service to offer this, but let’s not haggle and instead let’s remind everyone about the various efforts from Starz Vongo, iTunes itself, and competing film services from Google, Sony, Clear Channel; 4Flix and Blinkx in the US plus Arvato, BSkyB, LoveFilm and NTL in Europe and the fact that Amazon is preparing a launch in this sector, not to mention Netflix and Blockbuster, and DirecTV, all of whom are also preparing launches. Oh yes, and we forgot about Disney’s Moviebeam, which is datacast delivery now, moving to broadband soon.
In fact Disney would have to kill Moviebeam if it allowed the same movies out onto download sites at the same time as Moviebeam, and it’s not about to do that, so none of the above deals will have the latest Disney releases, and although Movielinnk statements said that negotiations with Disney are ongoing, it is not about to hurt their freshly salvaged Moviebeam service by offering exactly the same release dates for every other service. Twentieth Century Fox content is involved in this deal, even though it is not a Movielink shareholder.
Movielink’s biggest direct competitor, CinemaNow announced much the same download-to-own service in July last year, although was still selling mostly older classic films the. CinemaNow will can now upgrade to the latest release windows that Hollywood will allow it to sell, the same as Movielink. But it did cut a deal in February last year to take NBC Universal content as it hits the pay per view window, adjacent to DVD releases.
Movielink is one of the weakest online film rental sites with very low, but unrevealed revenues, and was set up by most of the major studios, not counting Disney and Twentieth Century Fox, which means that MGM, Paramount, Sony Pictures, Universal and Warner Brothers are driving this. At the time it said it was to stop piracy, but it behaved more like it was to stop anyone else offering an online film service.
There are a couple of things we must point out about this deal. First off all the other online film services MUST be offered the same early release dates for new films, or else there would be no arms length relationship between the studios and their jointly owned distribution, and that could imply preferring their own services, which in turns would point to a cartel. So everyone will get the same release dates that Movielink is offering. That’s why the announcement is so much bigger than everyone has initially stated.
Secondly the price is STILL wrong. New films will be priced at between $20 and $30 while older titles will sell for $10 to $20 and examples such as Brokeback Mountain, King Kong, and Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire were given in the release.
If you look at those films on Amazon today Brokeback Mountain costs $17, King Kong $15 and Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire $21 and for that customers get a DVD which will play on ANY device. Here customer have to own an expensive PC with DVD writing capabilities, it must also be a Windows PC with the latest edition of Windows Media DRM bundled onto it, and they have to pay for blank DVDs and burn them if they want the file to be played on any other device. Only two other ‘tethered’ PCs can be authorized to play that DVD, and this is arranged by a connection between the two PCs and the transfer of a hidden DRM key. Given that the margins on online retail are lower than retail, and that there are no DVD manufacturing costs, online services should be targeting $10 to $12 per film, not $20. But we suppose we should crawl before we run and lets get the system working first.
In order to play the film on a TV screen, Movielink customers will also need to own an expensive Media Center PC, so this is a huge boost for Microsoft devices if it is successful. It could underline the reasons why Microsoft has not been allowed to bundle media players, complete with DRM, into PCs in Europe and Korea, giving it a monopoly on services like this.
But we don’t think that Movielink is the core of this announcement. Instead, as other services get the same terms from Hollywood, and as they prove their own DRM is rigorous enough to offer the same level of protection, then many other services will come to market with slightly differing prices, packages and technologies. We suspect that the equivalent price for a film in the DVD release window will end up at $10 in a very short space of time, as these services use some films as loss leaders, and pay the studios the bulk of the fee, much as iTunes does on music tracks. Of course the studios may not allow this and could enforce a minimum retail price so that DVD revenues don’t fall off.
Just two months ago Movielink signed up with download to DVR pioneer Akimbo, which can take broadband delivered films directly to a $250 DVR attached to a TV set.
As an aggregation service for Internet delivered video, Akimbo already offers over 8,000 titles from more than 150 producers in 85 different genres. The number of titles will shortly exceed 10,000 and of course will include all the Movielink films. In this way Movielink is destined to become a kind of US only licensing arm, rather than a genuine retail proposition.
Finally there is another issue. Consumers want to view films over the internet on the same day they are released to cinema chains. Right now this is not going to happen, but as the Download on Demand (DoD) revenues begin to mount and become significant, and if piracy remains more or less where it is today (we think it should slowly decline) then the shrinking of release windows between Cinema and DVD release will slowly make the opportunity for Cinemas to make money evaporate.
We have long predicted the demise of the Cinema as a viable economic route to market for films, and as advertising shifts online more and more rapidly, and release windows continue and cinema will die. As Cinema revenues fall there will be an increasing shift to earlier and earlier online delivery to make up for the loss of cinema revenues, accelerating the decline.
This in turn will lead to new pricing models and new formula for release windows. For instance access to a Cinema release film online might cost $10 for rental, $20 to own, in the full knowledge that 3 months later the price will halve. There might even be a ‘lifetime ownership’ version where for a few dollars more, perhaps $30, your PC could download a further copy if anything happened to the first one (like it got deleted). This would likely give Studios the same amount of money or more for each family per film, but disintermediate both Cinemas and DVD retailers out of the loop. While we would expect this to be the final outcome, there will be a slow shift over perhaps ten year before that kind of model is reached.
As of now Movielink has divided its web site (www.movielink.com) into two “stores,” with a common home page. The two storefronts function just as the Movielink original “Rental Store” operated, but the license to view a movie obtained from the “Purchase Store” allows for unlimited viewing. The movie may be permanently stored on the hard drive to create a permanent archive, or burned to a disc in Windows Media format for backup or playback on up to two additional tethered computers. The movies can also be downloaded to a notebook computer for traveling. Using a Media Center Edition PC, consumers can stream their copy of the movie to a TV set connected to a media center extender or Xbox.
CinemaNow also said that it will source the same films and says it has signed deals with Sony Pictures Home Entertainment and Lionsgate to offer newer movies
UK online DVD service LoveFilm, which has just launched a film download site, says it has signed an agreement with film studio Momentum Pictures to offer downloads of 100 Momentum films. LoveFilm downloads are accessible on a seven day rental scheme and are available from the AOL UK online movie service site.