Qualcomm has warned, in a financial filing, that there is no guarantee it will come to agreement with Nokia over their CDMA patents licensing deal, which is due to be renewed in April.
It has taken the unusual step of singling out Nokia in the statement as a potential financial risk factor, indicating how strained relations between the two giants have become. Nokia cannot work around the Qualcomm patents, which are fundamental to several of its target growth businesses, notably CDMA and 3G W-CDMA handsets. But it wants to step up the pressure on the US company to agree to a cap on royalties in 3G cellphones, whose costs are kept artificially high by the levels of license payments.
It is also likely to want a short renewal term, perhaps as little as a year, so that it can quickly take advantage of any decisions by the European Commission to enforce new licensing practices on Qualcomm.
The EC is currently assessing antitrust complaints brought against the chipmaker by Nokia, Ericsson, Broadcom and other players, which are concerned at Qualcomm’s expansion into their heartland W-CDMA market. Of course, Nokia and Qualcomm will have to come to some sort of agreement, Nokia cannot live without the patents, nor challenge them, and Qualcomm would not easily lose the business of the world’s largest phonemaker, especially as Nokia steps up its assault on the CDMA market, through its alliances with Sanyo and Texas Instruments. With pressure mounting, some companies would seek to rethink their licensing policies to create a more harmonious relationship with key customers, but Qualcomm needs to play for time before its current business model plays out, and that may well mean taking its habitual intransigent stance.