Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 May 2006

French court drops DRM interoperability provision

A higher French select legal committee has dropped the contentious provision from its copyright law that would have placed the onus on companies using DRM on music services, to license it to other equipment makers. Although the law has more debating stages, its real aim was to catch France up with the World Copyright Treaty and make provisions that are similar to the US Digital Millenium Copyright Act, including making it illegal to break DRM and copy protection.

Apple and others had made protestations over the additional wording of the law which were clearly targeted at Apple’s iTunes service and its reluctance to license its Fairplay DRM to anyone else.

A lower court added the sections on DRM interoperability and in our analysis in March, we said that the new laws would be unworkable and would eventually be squashed, which has now happened.

Almost every European country has now passed a version of a law which supports the WCT, having been pressurized to do so by the European Commission. This includes the issue of citizens never interfering with content protection, even where this goes against local laws that say that content buyers are allowed to make personal copies of their purchased works.

EU trying to unify penalties for commercial piracy
A Reuters report says this week that the European Commission is about to unify European sanctions against counterfeiting and piracy, something the US has been trying to push for years. Piracy will incur at least four years in prison and up to $370,000 in fines if the legislation goes through.

There has been a marked increase in the number of counterfeit goods imported into Europe and the directive will aim to slow this by increasing penalties. At present the widely varying punishments across the EU make it easy to get counterfeit goods into the EU with little risk, and from there distribution is easy.

The legislation only deals with intellectual property that is stolen for commercial gain, and does not stiffen sanctions for private use.