German DRM specialist CoreMedia believes that no cellular operator will sign up with the MPEG LA licensing terms for OMA DRM.
Dr. Willms Buhse, Director Products & Marketing for CoreMedia talked frankly to Faultline this week, outlining the details behind its ground breaking deal with Microsoft, announced two weeks ago, to build a bridge between Windows DRM and OMA DRM.
CoreMedia provides the leading OMA DRM implementation and sits as the vice chair in the Open Mobile Alliance and risked having its entire business stalled by the call from an MPEG LA patent pool involving Intertrust, Philips, Sony, Matsushita, and ContentGuard, which called for initially $1 per handset plus usage fees, and then lowered this to $0.65 with a $.025 cap on usage fees per handset per annum.
Although this threatened to stall the OMA market, CoreMedia has struggled through and says today that there are 460 phones that support OMA DRM version 1.0 and that the first supporting version 2.0 is about to be announced, but no-one has yet signed with the MPEG LA group, as far as CoreMedia knows. Buhse says that 97% of multimedia phones will have OMA DRM.
Back in November Vodafone took the surprise step of licensing the DRM patents of Intertrust directly rather than pay the MPEG LA terms. These are the very same patents that have been at the center of a $440 million legal action that was successfully brought against Microsoft.
Vodafone effectively bypassed the MPEG LA group and decided to license only what it thought was necessary, the Intertrust patents, directly from the technology company.
”I think it was a case of Vodafone looking at the companies concerned and asking which ones were dangerous to it,’ said Buhse. Contentguard is owned by Microsoft, a big supplier to Vodafone, while Sony, Philips and Matsushita all want to chase Vodafone for future business.
‘It would be a case of gaining a few $ million in patent fees, but the loss of perhaps a few $100 millions, in lost business,’ explains Buhse. ‘I can’t say that the MPEG LA patent pool is dead, but I know there are others who have licensed the Intertrust patents and they are now approaching operators directly, and not via the pool.’
But the key question to CoreMedia is just why did Microsoft bang on their door to open up a bridge between Windows Media DRM and OMA DRM?
‘Microsoft had a major, as yet unannounced customer that wanted this capability,’ said Buhse. ‘What Microsoft wanted was strictly one way, from the phone to the PC, so that mobile phone content files could be stored on the PC under the safety of Windows Media DRM. But we have had to have a very close co-operation with Microsoft to do this and now, without further collaboration, with can supply a bridge that goes both ways,’ explained Buhse.
Once a route on and off the phone comes into existence in relative safety from piracy, then operators that are happy to tear down the ‘walled garden’ approach can offer a system of free transfer to and from the PC.
With this in place Microsoft could compete with the Apple iPod with a music service that sells to the PC and transfers to a mobile handset.
CoreMedia itself is trying to get into this business and now offers a services delivery platform for placing content directly onto mobile phones, and has had its software incorporated into the Nokia DVB-H development platform. CoreMedia software is also being used as a benchmark to establish compliance to the OMA standard.
‘Everyone is after building a handset DRM, but most of the traditional set top conditional access companies rely on things that make DRM very expensive (such as security chips).
The way the OMA Windows bridge works is that encrypted OMA content is transcoded directly into a new format that responds to a new Windows Media decryption key that is issued.
This effort could undermine entirely the Coral Consortium effort to build an interoperable DRM system. ‘We are in discussion with Coral, but it is important in DRM to have volume devices on your side. OMA DRM has a market among the 800 million handsets shipped each year, and Windows Media has all the PCs and others Windows devices. The only other device out there in volume is the iPod, and although we are frequent visitors to Apple in California, we don’t expect Apple to begin licensing its Fairplay any time soon,’ says Buhse.
‘Coral needs a market, and so far no clients have asked us to implement a bridge to Coral. If they do, then of course we would,’ he added. Intertrust and its Marlin Development Community this week announced that it has its own gateway into OMA, built into its first set of specifications, just released (see separate story).
But what about the open source DRM coming from Sun Microsystems, does that represent a threat to OMA DRM? ‘Sun is one of our long term partners, but writing specs and even implementing a system is not rocket science. Spending four years getting all the big companies in such a huge market to work together, as OMA has done, is a big achievement. Sun has not done that yet.
‘Of course OMA needs to evolve and you can bet that it will evolve in subsequent versions to where it pays even less in patent royalties, because today patent payments make up something like $30 in every phone, and that’s putting a tax on innovation, not rewarding it,’ he said.
CoreMedia DRM is already used at Vodafone, O2 and T-Online, and handset makers like Nokia and at chip maker Qualcomm and with that kind of momentum behind it, it could become the de factor bridge between the world of protected content on the PC, Xbox and Microsoft set tops and the mobile phone.