Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 May 2006

Warner Music reveals the tip of an iceberg of price fixing suits

In its latest filings at the Security and Exchange Commission, Warner Music Group revealed that the Attorney General in New York has been conducting an industry-wide investigation into the pricing of digital online music. Warner Music Group said it had several subpoenas requesting information and has subsequently been named in a total of fourteen class action lawsuits.

The legal actions, with five in New York, and eight in California and one in Washington DC, all relate to manipulating pricing of digital music downloads, and they are all expected to be consolidated into one case.

But if one company is guilty, they all are, and now the Attorney General is trying to work out if the record companies have collectively tried to fix the price for downloads.

Warner Group felt it had to reveal the actions as the company is likely to get embroiled in yet another long drawn out legal process, whether proved innocent or not.

Many of the US news papers have followed carefully the debate in which Apple has tried to keep all music valued at the same 99 cents, while the record labels have allegedly wanted to vary the price depending upon how much demand there is for the music.

Some online services have entered into ‘most favored nation’ contracts with the record labels, which means that if anyone gets a better deal than they, they can change and have the same terms.

This type of clause is notorious in creating these types of investigations, and we can only wait to see if the Attorney General thinks it has some substance.