Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 May 2006

More amendments to French copyright bill put forward

There is nothing but confusion coming from the proposed French law on music DRM interoperability, and this week a Reuters report, that confirmed that amendments were being made to the bill, still does nothing to clarify whether or not the law will be passed in its current form.

It all started when the lower house put in a provision into a new copyright bill that made a DRM supplier obliged to offer interoperability with another DRM supplier in order to promote the free transfer of DRM protected material from one device to another.

This would effectively end the Apple iTunes hegemony, but as no-one appears to have yet picked up, would also mean that cable TV operators would have a major problem unless the bill was specifically for music only, which is a bit nonsensical as copyright is copyright.

The French senate have made the suggestion that a license payment must be made by the device manufacturer that is being allowed to ingest the content, payable to the original DRM holder. This would be managed by a new independent authority which would review demands for DRM information transfers.

This is tantamount to the French telling everyone in the world how they will or will not do business and we repeat, this law is not going to fly, and if it does, it will last about 5 minutes before it is repealed or challenged in a European court.

The amendments to the original wording are all in secret anyway, and these are just leaks, and when a final wording is agreed upon it must reconcile the original wording with any amendments suggested and then be voted through.

Apple still looks on track to pull out of France with iTunes if this legislation goes ahead, and the roar from the French public will be immense. The French public recently went to the streets to convince the government not to amend employment legislation, and we wouldn’t be surprised if it did the same over having its iTunes taken away.