Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 May 2006

Labels XM action is a ‘negotiating tactic’ for a bigger license

Reading between the lines of the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) legal action against XM Satellite Radio, this all appears to be little more that a marketing tactic by the rival Sirius Satellite Radio, which is slightly lagging XM in its development.

Sirius makes no secret of the fact that it has bought rights from the RIAA to allow its customers to download and store, but not transfer songs, from its satellite radio service. The obvious corollary to this is that if another satellite radio company (that means XM in the US) does NOT have such an agreement, then the RIAA is duty bound to take legal action to either get them to pay the same, or to stop them allowing their content to be stored.

If it turns out that what XM is doing is not at all illegal, then whatever Sirius has paid them, will have been unnecessary.

US law on this point is far from clear and XM has issued a reaction this week saying that what it is doing is entirely legal, and that it will fight the action in court to continue its services.

The argument is about XM selling radios that allow the store and replay of up to 50 hours of music. The big difference here is that in order to seed the market for satellite radios with a national footprint, both XM and Sirius have had to bring the devices themselves to market, specifying them and finding manufacturers for them. This is not the case for the local radio station, and all they have to do is send out music on the airwaves.

These new devices are sold under the slogan ‘hear it, click it, save it,’ and the resulting music store ends up with the type of recorded store usually associated with an iPod.

As such the RIAA sees what XM does as selling copies of its songs, while XM sees this as the age old US right of allowing citizens to make copies of radio programs to listen to later. There are substantial differences, in that iTunes delivered songs are burnable into a CD which can be played on multiple devices, and this is not the case with the new breed of satellite players just launched.

And if it transpires that existing laws are not sufficient to bring XM to heel, then there are moves afoot in Congress, both in terms of mandating content protection technologies and in copyright laws which would ensure that this was licensed more like iTunes than like a radio station.

That would come as good news to the 13,000 or so US radio stations that are jeopardized by the very existence of satellite radio, and which have more or less all been written down dramatically in terms of their financial worth, due to the gradual lowering of their ability to generate advertising revenues, due entirely to the existence of satellite radio.

The lawsuit filed last week in New York by the largest record labels, seeks $150,000 in damages for every song copied by XM Satellite customers using its new devices, and given that the company plays some 160,000 different songs every month, that’s likely to come to a huge fee in the unlikely outcome that XM is found guilty.

The legal action has not targeted customers of XM, but the company would be forced to pass on any negotiated license fee costs to its customers, something that Sirius is licking its lips at.

In a statement XM Satellite Radio said, ‘These are legal devices that allow consumers to listen to and record radio just as the law has allowed for decades. The music labels are trying to stifle innovation, limit consumer choice and roll back consumers’ rights to record content for their personal use.’

In an unrelated move, electronics maker Audiovox has withdrawn one of its XM Satellite receivers after the FCC said the device fails to comply bandwidth and emission specifications, and will now try to bring it into line with FCC rules.