Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 May 2006

VC firms flock to M2Z and its universal broadband promises

Having been badly burned by the last broadband wireless bubble at the start of the century, the investment community, while excited by Wi-Fi, has been wary of longer range technologies that could challenge the telcos in the developed economies. That looks set to change in the face of spectrum auctions in the US, Europe and elsewhere, combined with the prospect of new telecoms models with relatively short term return.

Investors have been flocking to fairly small spectrum buyers in the European 3.5GHz space, but a far greater prize awaits in the US with the upcoming June auction of AWS bandwidth around 1.7GHz and 2.1GHz.

Last week saw broadband wireless start-up Clearwire filing for a $400m IPO that could be part of a plan to buy spectrum to add to the company’s existing 2.5GHz holdings, and now three high profile hi-tech venture capitalists are backing a bid by M2Z Networks to gain 20MHz of spectrum for a free access network, funded by advertising and likely to use WiMAX-type technology.

M2Z is headed by John Muleta, formerly head of the FCC’s wireless bureau, and Milo Medin, founder of @Home. They claim they can fulfill the goal set by the Bush administration’s broadband policy and by the FCC itself in Muleta’s day, of making broadband access available to 95% of the US population, mainly using wireless to fill current rural gaps and to reduce the cost of services even in well served areas, by offering an alternative to the incumbent telcos and cellcos.

The company has already applied to bid for a 20MHz license in the 2.1GHz band in the June auction, but it may also have asked the FCC for an outright allocation of spectrum.

This raises an issue that is becoming increasingly important in territories where governments have decided that universal broadband is essential to economic and social progress, in order to achieve that universal access, should spectrum be awarded for free, or at low cost, to operators promising to achieve this with a creative business model? This is a debate that has started taking hold in Europe, where approaches range from that of some Scandinavian regulators, which traditionally award licenses at very low cost to the providers promising to meet government objectives while making a profit; to the lobbying of ISPs such as Metranet in the UK, which wants one of the forthcoming 2.5GHz licenses, originally earmarked for 3G expansion, to be set aside for public sector ownership, to support low cost access and social inclusion programs.

Such a socially oriented tactic is unlikely to succeed in the US, but the Google experiment in San Francisco has highlighted the potential for alternative operators to gain the support of the authorities ‘ whether in terms of funding, infrastructure or favored access to spectrum ‘ if they can provide low cost networks and services, funded by new commercial models such as advertising.

This is the plan of M2Z Networks, which is backed by the venture capital firms Kleiner Perkins Caufield Byers, Redpoint Ventures and Charles River Ventures, and which claims it can raise up to $400m ‘ a similar figure to that targeted by the planned Clearwire IPO.

Furthermore, reports claim it has proposed that, in return for uncontested award of an AWS license, it would return 5% of revenues to the government to boost broadband initiatives. Whether or not M2Z succeeds in its quest, it forms part of a general flight of venture capital funds into new broadband services, backed by creative revenue models and seeking to leverage the increasing willingness of regulators to take more flexible stances in order to achieve government access targets.