Nano-Proprietary, the inappropriately named holding company which is pressing for the use of carbon nanotubes in the building of large flat TV screens has signed a deal with one of the world’s largest trading companies, Japan’s Mitsui.
On the surface this will look like something of a victory for Nano Propietary and its operating subsidiary Applied Nanotech, but over the year’s we have seen technologies disappear into Mitsui, which at the time seemed ripe for underpinning new markets.
The simple truth is that Mitsui rarely, if ever, manufactures anything and right now what Nano-Proprietary needs more than anything is a manufacturing partner for TVs. It is supposed to already have one in the shape of a Taiwanese partner recently announced, but that is vastly underfunded, and unlikely to ever result in devices.
The deal with Mitsui is really about taking the financial clout of Mitsui, which is considerable, and using it to back the Applied Nanotech technology and introduce it to Japanese partners, and to aim it at new applications of technology other than as a TV screen. But wherever it is targeted it will come up against the prevalent and established LCD technology. Carbon Nanotubes offer applications that are not screen based, due to their enormous strength compared to some metals, but so far most successes have come on screen technology.
This is where Carbon nanotubes are used to create tiny, segregated vacuum tubes, ideal to build screens that effectively have millions of separate Cathode Ray Tubes (CRTs) on them, creating devices a few centimeters thick with the clarity of CRT TVs, and Nano-Proprietary has over 200 patents or patent applications pending in this field.
Its recent deal with Taiwanese Da Ling corporation is to build a plant for making flat TV screens around the technology and it is also chasing market leader Canon with a patent infringement legal action.
Canon is supposed to be working with Toshiba to bring its SED (surface-conduction electron-emitter display) TVs to market, using what is a similar technology. But recently the Toshiba Canon joint venture confirmed that it would take 15 months longer than previously expected to bring the concept to market. Faultline believes that this decision means that LCD screens will build up too much of a lead, and will go on to dominate large TV screen technology for the foreseeable future.
Canon and Toshiba may well have spent more than $2 billion on development costs by the time they abandon the approach, while Nano-Proprietary is working with far less money than that.
The 50:50 joint venture called Carbon Nanotube Televisions that it has with Da Ling was formed around the contribution of just $10 million of equipment shoved into the joint venture, plus an unspecified amount of funding. If this was going to work, it begs the question of just why Nano Proprietary needs a deal with Mitsui at all.
The Taiwanese joint venture was supposed to have produced 60 inch to 100 inch flat screen TVs which can retail for as low as $1,300, a boast that now seems unlikely.
By our calculations, if such a device is not on the market within 18 months it will already be too late to stop LCD technology dominating, given that it is already in he market and 8th generation LCD plants will be in operation by then. The market looks like it will become dominated by Sony and Samsung and a handful of other suppliers who can afford to spend $billions protecting their existing TV revenues.
As part of the new Mitsui agreement Applied Nanotech’s development team will work with Mitsui’s wholly-owned subsidiary Bussan Nanotech Research Institute.