While the dam has yet to burst with any meaningful numbers of video downloads over the internet, there are still services being launched everywhere, and this week there are two, one from UK online music store Wippit, which has added video to its remit, through a deal with Universal and video-sharing site Guba in the US has signed a second distribution deal, this one with Sony Pictures for its top 100 films.
Faultline had proudly proclaimed in January that 2006 was the year of the video download. We can now confirm that we were wrong. This is the year of the studios getting video download wrong. These deals have been rolling out at the speed of treacle dripping from a spoon, as the entire video download market is sabotaged by high pries, speculative business models and greed.
After telling the world proudly that Sony would have 500 films available for online services by the end of 2005, the Guba deal is the first deal of this type we have seen, while Universal is ensuring that its online film services can do no harm to its existing distribution means by insisting that online services sell film for ludicrously high prices.
Back in March Universal announced its first deal with UK online DVD rental firm Lovefilm with films priced at £19.99 (around $35) for premium films.
In the US the average price for a DVD is just $11 to $15, in the UK it is around £13 to £15. The good things about this service, is that it has recent films such as King Kong on it and that you also get a DVD (posted to you afterwards) as well as a file that will play on your PC and another that will play on a portable player. But that’s actually where the thinking is muddled.
The Wippit deal has been cut on exactly the same terms, and it appears to us that there will be very few takers for this type of service. In contrast Apple is thought to be working on a download service built around $9.99 per film download, roughly a third of the price.
People either want to download a film for instantaneous play, or they can wait until Amazon can ship them a DVD. Amazon UK has the same films on DVD for $12.99 ($22.70) so if anyone wants to own a DVD long term that’s where they’ll go.
The whole idea of online delivery is that content companies can dis-intermediate from DVD manufacture and retail. They save themselves the cost of DVD mass production and cut the retailer out of such a generous margin (usually 50%) and the customers themselves can burn their own DVD if they need to. All they need is a file transferred to them which can be used right away on a TV or PC, which can be burned to a DVD, and that can also be slimmed down automatically (by a downloaded application?) to play on a mobile device.
By continuing to go through the DVD manufacturing process and adding the costs of online delivery, the studio is making online film delivery more expensive than retail and not less. They are doing this to protect and maintain their distribution chain, not to dis-intermediate it. That might be fine if it was simultaneous with cinema launch of the film, but not when it is coming out on DVD at the same time.
We have to applaud Wippit for its introductory offer though. Downloads will be priced from £4.99 (old films) up to £19.99 per title (DVD window), with a special introductory deal of 3 titles for £20 for a limited period. That makes them £7 or $12.60 each, still not quite as low as iTunes hopes to go, and probably the cost price they are being offered to Wippit at.
Most people wouldn’t care if the file they downloaded could only be played on a single device which downloaded it or any devices that could attach directly to such a device. The same for the DVD, most people would be fine if a download and burn to a DVD could only be played on a player that had been registered, so that piracy could be prevented more easily.
What they are not going to be happy doing is paying almost double the going rate to see a film just because they want it online. ‘Online is free,’ is the mentality of piracy, so this won’t compete with it. iTunes competed with piracy, because it was a better content acquisition process.
The Lovefilm Universal service started back in April 10 and was extended in Scandinavia the following month and is currently limited to an initial collection of 35 movies and Wippit is launching it now.
By imposing these terms Universal is hampering these new services and the only way they will survive is by other studios offering better terms, and the Universal content being left out to dry, or by Universal gradually learning from the experience and changing the model.
Paul Myers, Wippit Founder and CEO, added, ‘Having Universal as our first major movie supplier is a huge step forward for Wippit, our customers and for film fans alike. We are offering our customers the best in big screen entertainment, with only a couple of keystrokes of effort. And more importantly, these movies are permanent, not rentals. These movies are yours forever’.
Wippit made its name by being original with online music offerings and has 1,000,000 tracks on its service in MP3 format with prices as low as 29p ($0.54) each, and has an unlimited downloads model priced at £50 ($90) a year giving access to the core 60,000 or so tracks.
Meanwhile Guba is the first site we have come across to add some of the 8,000 strong films that Sony and its various studios, including MGM, owns. Sony has been saying for over a year that these films will be available, and even launched them experimentally in flash memory versions, with a less than enthusiastic response, but this is the first US operation we have come across that has actually loaded them and put them up for sale.
Guba landed a film deal with Warner Brothers for 200 films last month and now adds the Sony top 100 films to its collection. Both are geographical restricted to US distribution and both are only available for distribution using Windows Media DRM.
This pricing is a little different from the Universal Films pricing. New releases will cost $19.99 from both studios, with older titles around $9.99 in a download to own format. Warner Brothers will also rent its content with prices starting at $1.99 per movie for unlimited views during a 24-hour period. Viewers can buy extra viewing days for reduced fees without the need to download the film again.
Guba is also offering television shows starting at $1.79 per episode (but we suspect these will be mostly at $1.99 like iTunes). Users may keep permanent copies of purchased titles, load purchased titles onto portable devices, and stream purchased and rented content through their home network.
Guba says there are more announcements coming, but really these deals are around 6 to nine months behind the recent spate of video download services announced. There are also improvements to the three years old Movielink and CinemaNow services, and the various efforts from Starz Vongo, iTunes itself, and competing film services from Google, Sony, Clear Channel; 4Flix and Blinkx in the US plus Arvato, BSkyB, LoveFilm and NTL in Europe and the fact that Amazon is preparing a launch in this sector, not to mention Netflix and Blockbuster, and DirecTV, all of whom are also preparing launches, plus Disney’s revitalized Moviebeam service which is shortly to go to broadband delivery.
Only iTunes has announced any details of the numbers of videos delivered while other services continue to be waiting for someone else to spark the online download film market.