Broadband wireless operator Clearwire has received $900m in financing from the two companies that have staked the most on WiMAX, Intel and Motorola, ensuring that the US will gain a national 802.16 network, and putting pressure on both Qualcomm and Samsung in the mobile broadband race.
Intel Capital has invested $600m in Clearwire, its largest ever funding, and Motorola is paying a further $300m to take over the operator’s equipment arm, NextNet, and to gain an unspecified stake. (As a result, Clearwire has cancelled its planned IPO, avoiding the pressures of public scrutiny, a route that will better suit its secretive nature.)
This is an important decision for all three partners, and for WiMAX itself. Despite all the momentum behind the technology, there has been a serious need for major action to follow all the talk, since to date the only large scale deployments based on the 802.16e mobile version of the standard have been those of Korea Telecom and SKT, using Samsung’s pre-certified Wi-Bro variant. Amid market skepticism engendered by an initially slow certification process and product roll-out, the Wi-Bro projects did at least lend credibility to the platform, but they brought competitive problems of their own for Intel, since Samsung has explicitly said it aims to wrest control of the WiMAX agenda from the US chipmaker, pushing a roadmap geared around handsets rather than PCs, and aiming to claim a global market for Asian suppliers and chipmakers.
The US contingent, then, needed a flagship roll-out of their own, which would drive their own objectives – Intel’s to make Wi-Fi and WiMAX the basis of ubiquitous wireless and so sell more chips, initially in laptops and later in a host of other devices; Motorola’s to compensate for the loss of its largest customer, the Nextel iDen network, and for its failure in W-CDMA, by promoting and dominating a next generation global platform, and taking the lead in handsets too. And they needed one quickly, since the pressure on 802.16e has been mounting rapidly in the past year, with the 3GPP development of a next generation for W-CDMA accelerating in response, and Qualcomm becoming ever more aggressive against WiMAX, touting its own OFDM and CDMA-based alternatives.
With such aims at stake, almost a billion dollars is a small price to pay. Given that Clearwire has already raised at least $600m ($200m of that from Intel), and likely closer to $1bn, it is now within striking distance of the estimated $3bn required to create a US-wide network in 2.5GHz (though most of its ongoing revenue will disappear with the sale of NextNet, at least until its access services gather momentum. So far, Clearwire has launched in about 25 midsized US markets and several European countries, claiming about 5% penetration of the broadband base, and has a major roaming/investment agreement with Inukshuk, the Bell Canada/Rogers joint venture north of the border.
So Craig McCaw’s venture was an obvious vehicle for Intel’s and Motorola’s ambitions, though it does raise the question of Sprint Nextel, which would have been an even better one. Sprint, the largest holder of 2.5GHz spectrum in the US, is in the process of making a decision on which technology to deploy, and should announce its choice soon. It has been considering a Qualcomm solution, which would incorporate extensions of its existing CDMA2000 EV-DO network plus the Flash-OFDM broadband wireless technology; IPWireless’ TD-CDMA, with a specialized television add-on called TDtv (Sprint has also invested in the vendor); and 802.16e, carrying out trials with two vendors, Motorola and Samsung (with Intel involved in both). The operator’s decision is closely watched and vital to all bidders – Motorola badly needs to replace the iDen business as Nextel phases out that network; Samsung is keen to build an international business for Wi-Bro; IPWireless has perhaps its only chance of a contract large enough to ensure its survival; and a decision against Qualcomm would send out very negative signals at a time when some operators are considering a move away from CDMA and looking to Sprint as a bellwether.
The Clearwire deal seems to imply that Sprint has not chosen Motorola WiMAX, since it might be unlikely to want to purchase from the same supplier as the other major 2.5GHz holder – although it has previously entered into spectrum sharing or exchange agreements with the McCaw company, choosing to regard the incumbent RBOCs as its competition rather than Clearwire. This mentality could lead it to entertain a broader alliance with the smaller operator, such as a broad roaming agreement, in which case a common supplier would not be a problem. Indeed, some analysts believe Intel has announced the Clearwire deal in order to nudge Sprint towards WiMAX, to gain the benefits of a roaming alliance.
The Sprint deal is not out of the window then, but seems less likely, which would be a major blow to WiMAX, especially if the winner is Qualcomm, whose position that CDMA with OFDM extensions is stronger than a brand new network, would be strengthened. But at least the Clearwire agreement ensures Motorola a major customer for its forthcoming 802.16e MotoWi4 equipment, and WiMAX a national US network, and one that will be built out ahead of Sprint’s. Before this, Clearwire had been a cheerleader for mobile broadband, but had been vague in its commitment to WiMAX. Beyond a general pledge that it, and NextNet, would support the standard in future releases, it was in no rush to do so as long as its own systems were driving business – owning its own source of kit, it was not under the same economic pressures to adopt open standards as other operators, and NextNet never came out with an aggressive technical progress chart towards 802.16e as, for instance, Navini has done.
That will all change now that NextNet’s Expedience system will be submerged into MotoWi4. The purchase clears the way for Motorola to gain the second largest US customer for broadband wireless – a move Alcatel is hoping to make at BellSouth at the expense of the RBOC’s current 2.3GHz kit supplier Navini – but it also continues Motorola’s recent habit of purchasing innovative start-ups to bolster the Wi4 arsenal as rapidly as possible. NextNet will bring it several useful technical additions, not least the joint development for smart antennas that it has with Arraycomm and Intel. It will also, of course, bring its non-Clearwire customer base, notably Inukshuk, which plans a national Canadian network, and MVS in Mexico, giving Motorola the prospect of a pan-north American customer base at a stroke.
Not that this is all about tactical customer wins. Intel and Motorola are spending a far more symbolic billion dollars than that, and cementing their own growing partnership into the bargain. This is about throwing down a very heavy gauntlet to the WiMAX naysayers, and investing to ensure the technology happens, and that it happens before the 3GPP developments can progress sufficiently far to eclipse it. This is a war cry directed at Qualcomm and, to a lesser extent, Samsung, seeking to pull some of the driving force behind WiMAX back from Seoul and towards Intel and the US.
It is only a first step though, and in a market that, though large, has always been an oddity in terms of international mobile communications choices. Whether Intel likes it or not, the growing operator support for an Asian roaming belt based on Wi-Bro will be more significant even than a US national network for the future of WiMAX. Indeed, it will be important for the vendors to pay close attention to Clearwire’s non-US activities, particularly in China and Latin America, as a source of potential roaming and international influence down the road.
International adoption/roaming is one critical issue for the future success of WiMAX. There are two other key uncertainty factors – the handset, and Microsoft. WiMAX is not short of handset support now – Motorola’s grasping of the front seat may increase Nokia’s ambivalence towards the technology, but the Finnish giant’s development project with Intel continues, and its increasing love affair with open IP and Wi-Fi suggests it will embrace WiMAX more eagerly in future. And of course Samsung has already shown off the first prototype cellphones for WiMAX and dual-mode.
More doubtful, though, is who will drive the chipsets for these handsets? To produce devices that will support high end multimedia services, plus roaming with other networks like 3G or Wi-Fi (essential to fill gaps in WiMAX coverage), and that will also be cost effective, will require highly integrated chipsets of the type that Texas Instruments and Qualcomm are producing for W-CDMA and EV-DO. But Intel has sold off its XScale cellphone architecture, Qualcomm is hostile, Broadcom uncommitted, and TI and Freescale, though making WiMAX chips, not putting it at the center of their agendas. This raises the risk that a truly advanced chipset will be slow to appear, putting the initiative back with the 3GPP/2 communities, and confining WiMAX to portable, rather than mobile, applications.
And what of Microsoft? Its near-silence on WiMAX contrasts with its (admittedly costly) enthusiasm for broadband wireless in the late 1990s, when it realized even before Intel that this technology could make the Wintel architecture, rather than the cellular platforms, the basis of the new wireless world; and with its important support for Wi-Fi in its early days, which helped establish the network rapidly on the notebook.
WiMAX should present a huge opportunity for Microsoft. By optimizing its systems for 802.16e, it could make Windows/.Net devices a natural fit and finally find a way to move its technologies on to mobile, licensed spectrum networks – something that has proved very hard for it in the cellular world. With the cellcos suspicious of it, Microsoft needs another route into the mobile broadband world, especially when Wi-Fi starts to run out of steam and more premium users turn to licensed networks. Microsoft could tap into its old alliance with Intel and its new-found friendship with Motorola to take a piece of their accelerating WiMAX activities, and use that not only to boost Windows, but also to push its middleware and server-based architectures in a world that has not yet made its key technology choices.
Like other key players such as Nokia, Microsoft needs to make decisions quickly. The mobile broadband battle is speeding up, and no major vendor or operator should allow themselves to be left out of it – whichever platform they decide to back.