The showdown between the European Commission and a recalcitrant Microsoft flared up again this week two years after it fined the US software company $600 million in the Spring of 2004.
Microsoft continues to play the innocent and says it will appeal, but the Commission is clear that Microsoft has not released certain server based protocols, although it has created a version of Windows without Media Player, the two thrusts of the anti-trust judgement.
The result is another fine of $356 million for delays that have happened since December until June. The Commission says this amounts to $1.5 million a day and that it will now raise this to double that amount for further delays beyond July 31.
“I don’t buy Microsoft’s line that they didn’t know what was being asked of them, because the March 2004 order is absolutely crystal clear,” said Neelie Kroes, the Commission’s competition commissioner when she spoke at a press conference this week. ‘And in order to increase the incentive for Microsoft to comply, the Commission has decided the ceiling for potential fines will be raised.”
Microsoft either just doesn’t get it, or thinks that the US government will somehow bale it out. As Microsoft prepares for the launch of its next operating system it is aiming to bundle yet more services into its, blissfully unaware that this is no longer going to be accepted by either Europe or the rest of Corporate America.
Neelie Kroes also made references to the forthcoming launch of Microsoft Vista and made it clear that bundling things like a PDF creator, which would marginalize Adobe, or an internet search engine, targeting Google, are not acceptable and that failing to provide interface information would also not be acceptable, and yet there is every indication that this is exactly what Microsoft plans to do at the launch. Even if the EC did not step in, both Google and Adobe are likely to reach for legal remedy.
But Microsoft clearly has some legitimate beef with this order. It resolved issues with the Commission’s monitoring trustee, Neil Barrett in April and developed a template to enter batches of protocols and a schedule of deadlines.
Since that date it has thrown 300 people at the problem. Neelie Kroes, while acknowledging this points out that if Microsoft had taken the problem seriously two years ago, instead of spending all of its time and energies appealing and playing dumb, then it would have been further along.
Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith said that Microsoft would appeal the rule and called it “unjustified” pointing out that this is a larger fine the EC has imposed for price-fixing cartels.
“When you consider Microsoft’s massive efforts to comply with this ruling, and the fact that more than a dozen companies are already using similar documentation provided in the US to ship actual products, we do not believe this fine is justified,” he said in a statement.
The more this type of court defiance continues, the more investors will begin to move out of Microsoft in droves, and those that remain have to ask if $956 million (in total) is enough of a hit to require Microsoft’s CEO to stand down. But to put this in perspective, it is still only one month’s net income.