The gadget wires and websites are beside themselves with glee at the prospect of a Microsoft iPod killer coming out in the very near future, like in time for this Christmas, but we thought Microsoft had already launched two iPod killers and both had failed.
The confusion in the reports coming out is that some are throwbacks to March when the idea of a tiny handheld Xbox was doing the rounds (we dubbed it Xboy) which was under design now and due in the market in around 2008. Some people are seeing that as the device likely to be launched, but it sounds very different, and anyway, how did Microsoft bypass two years of development.
Other reports have it that the new beast looks far more like an iPod. But you can’t get much more like an iPod than the new second generation Portable Media Centers. Back in March they featured extended battery life, higher-resolution displays on wider screens, and could be used with the Starz Vongo film download service, and music, video and audio books from brands such as Audible.com, MSNBC, Comedy Central, Cookie Jar Entertainment, Fox Sports, MTV, Napster and TiVo at prices between $299 and $399. The Toshiba version is pictured below, So why wouldn’t the iPod killer simply be one of these, perhaps with wi-fi added, with perhaps a central download site for films and music, like iTunes?
Some reports have it that Microsoft is actually building the things, but it is much better off offering a route into the market for Toshiba and other majors to help them claw back market share against Apple and of course the Sony PSP. Microsoft is unlikely, in our view, to jeopardize its relationships with companies like Samsung and Toshiba by going it alone, and anyhow would simply fail. It already shifted from no-brand Chinese manufacture of its first generation PMCs to top brand builders of its second generation devices.
But lots of US papers were talking about briefings from company executives of a device with wi-fi, able to download without being connected to a PC (the news PMC devices were supposed to offer that). But no figures have been released on these second generation PMC devices, and if they are already in need of an update, it can only be because the market has ignored them yet again.
What seems really at the heart of this is that Microsoft has stepped in when Apple was in danger of stealing the film download market and said to studios, don’t choose them, choose us and promised a quick and dirty fix.
The probable outcome, for the good of the studios, would be if it chose both of them. It could have the existing power of the Apple installed base of iTunes and iPods, and future competition from all the CE vendors working on a Microsoft inspired architecture. Except that most of the CE vendors would operate a Microsoft architecture over their dead body.
In fact this whole scam seems like such an open story that it would not surprise us if it turns out to be cooked up by the studios in order to give it a negotiating hand against Apple. Good luck with that strategy, I wouldn’t want to be on the wrong side of Steve Jobs in that kind of game of bluff.
Meanwhile Apple has filed a patent, reveals Gizmondo, which suggests that future iPods will be able to talk. The idea is that you pick the celebrity you’d most like to introduce your playlists and they introduce each record or video personally, with computer generated outputs.
The voice processing would be done by the Mac as the files are uploaded to the iPod and are triggered by the clickwheel trawling over the track name. Why not throw in an ethereal video image of them at the same time?