Get set for another round of copyright mania as German vested interests mount pressure against a final parliamentary vote to accept new copyright legislation that is based on the Digital Millenium Copyright Act.
The German law, long ridiculed for its obsessive implementations of excessive levies on storage media, disk drives, and PCs, is also using the opportunity to rid itself of many of its levies for storage media. Why pass a law that talks about making it illegal to interfere with copy protection and then continue to charge levies on blank material.
But the result is that the collections organizations have joined the lobby process and are writing articles, letters of complaint and pressing government ministers to vote down the proposals. The German collections societies are among the oldest institutions in the world, claiming royalties from the dim and distant days of when copyright was first invented.
In our view levies are an outmoded and unfair way of rewarding existing monopolies and are only ever put in place to keep ancient publishing copyright agencies in business. In almost every case the organization itself that carries out the collection is lavish and well funded, the proceeds are distributed only to large multinational music publishers, bolstering their revenues unfairly. It is little more than a club of companies that ‘have a right’ to make money.
In the Netherlands last year, copying Germany, there was new legislations proposed which would add a surcharge of €3.28 ($4.3) per gigabyte of disk storage which would have had the effect of putting €180 ($235) to the price of a top end iPod.
In Germany there has always been a levy on PC hard drives, which relates to storage capacity. If this was left in place it would soon outweigh not just the cost of the drive, but the cost of the device. Germany also charges a TV license to any mobile phone that can take mobile TV, despite the fact that the public broadcasting channels have not yet been put on a mobile TV.
Not only are the collections agencies going to fight this new law, but university academics and professors are up in arms over rewording of personal use laws, and the German Music Council is saying it will be detrimental to performing artists and the record industry, but that’s mostly due to the dropping of recorded materials levies.
But the way European law works, the paragraphs relating to copyright protection cannot be removed from the law, as they are part of a European Directive and the entire point of implementing a law in the first place.
Presumably Germany will get through this, as France did, but the more liberal countries such as the Netherlands and parts of Scandinavia may baulk at implementing a law that the US originator is already looking at amending.