Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 July 2006

Tiscali refuses music industry names of accused file sharers

Tiscali, the Italian ISP which operates across Europe, has been requested by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) in the UK to suspend the internet accounts of 17 people accused of illegal file sharing. But the ISP has gone public over the issue, saying that the BPI has failed to provide any evidence of wrongdoing.

This week the BPI wrote an open letter to both Tiscali and Cable & Wireless demanding that 59 customers it said it had identified as illegally sharing copyrighted music should be cut off.

While Cable & Wireless said it would investigate, Tiscali came back and said that it was unimpressed with the level of proof that BPI considered adequate. Tiscali said that the BPI only offered proof against one individual and expected Tiscali to acts on the BPI’s say so over the others.

Tiscali wrote to the one customer asking for an explanation and is now awaiting further proof from the BPI over the others.

Tiscali pointed out that providing alleged date and times of infringement, and screenshots of shared drives of just one customer, without showing what IP address it was connected to, did not constitute proof and that if it handed over the names it would be in breach of the UK data protection act.

The BPI will now have to convince a judge that it should file a court order to hand over the names of the IPS customers.

It appears that broadband access is an inalienable right, as long as you are not accused by the music industry of doing anything wrong, then even if your job depends on internet access, it is happy to have you cut off, even without proof.

This battle between ISPs and the music industry was fought in the US two to three years ago, and a procedure established. With the differing laws in Europe and a different approach to privacy and the rights of the individual in Europe, the same outcome is not assured.