Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 July 2006

AMD ATI deal may push Intel’s hand into the graphics chip pie

News that AMD has stepped up and offered $5.4 billion, mostly in cash, for graphics chip maker ATI, has set Wall Street re-thinking just what these chips are all about.

For us on Faultline we see ATI as the number two graphics chip maker to Nvidia and the two fighting it out over exclusive supply of the graphics engines in all three of the top games platforms Sony, Nintendo and Microsoft.

But for Wall Street analysts the market for them is about the graphics on a PC card and the ludicrous positioning that most AMD processor boards are currently going out with Nvidia chips. In buying ATI, AMD shoots a huge hole in Nvidia, and accelerates ATI, by switching supply, so goes the logic.

Of course the corollary is true. If Intel wants any graphics chips for its motherboard then will it continue taking some from each of Nvidia and ATI, or will it drop ATI like a stone? So that logic cuts both ways.

At present Nvidia has pride of place in the forthcoming Sony PS3, which should outsell, at a higher price, all the other gaming platforms put together. But it has the disadvantage of not currently being on the market and that won’t change until November, although it is currently in manufacture and two million are under order. Nvidia is still thought to be supplying plenty of chips for the existing PS2 range and is widely thought to be providing the next generation graphics chip for the iPod, again not confirmed and also not currently shipping, though it will soon going into manufacture.

ATI on the other hand is embedded in the now shipping Xbox 360, having taken the role away from Nvida, who supplied it to the preceding Xbox design. So that is shipping in quantity. ATI is also understood to be supplying the graphics chip to the forthcoming Revolution home platform from Nintendo.

The question on everyone’s lips right now is whether or not this means that Nvidia as a company needs to be sold. The logic for that is buried deep within the idea that the PC chip makers have reached virtual saturation for the parts they make, as the PC industry growth rate begins to head to under 10% per annum, with prices still falling.

One way to counter that is to make more of the chips in any given PC. For AMD this deal spreads the risk from just competing head on with Intel, to competing with a new apparently weak Nvidia.

But again there is a corollary. Nvidia was almost certainly asked to be acquired by AMD before it asked ATI. Why ignore your main graphics chip supplier, and go after the chip maker you rarely work with? Nvidia almost certainly said ‘No thanks,’ the result is the purchase of ATI. But Intel must now take a look at the revitalized AMD and decide for itself if it too needs to be making its own high end graphics chips.

If the answer is yes, and it’s likely that it will be, then Intel can go one of two ways, it can start designing rapidly or buy Nvidia. Either way that puts AMD pretty much back at square one.

Nvidia announced just last week that it has won the graphics chip supply for HP’s three latest notebooks, the HP Pavilion Entertainment Notebooks and a Presario branded notebook.

Nvidia already works with Apple, Dell, Fujitsu Siemens, Gateway, HP, IBM, Lenovo, LG, Medion, Mitsubishi, Motorola, MPC, NEC, Samsung, Sony Electronics, Sony Ericsson, and Toshiba in PCs, so that new deal is not such a surprise.

Under terms of the deal AMD will pay $4.2 billion in cash and 57 million AMD shares to acquire all of ATI’s outstanding stock. Not only did the ATI shares rise slightly on the news, and AMD fall slightly, as often happens to the acquiring firms, but Nvidia shares rose quite dramatically, by 11%, on the logic that Intel or someone might move to bid for Nvidia.

If Intel does make that move, Nvidia could be bought for stock, and even with a premium Intel would need to pay less than 7% of its total market capitalization.