Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 July 2006

Rumors reverberate on DirecTV EchoStar merger

We suppose that we should put in our two cents worth on the rumor that refuses to die that EchoStar and DirecTV may be preparing to merge.

Both the News Corp CEO Rupert Murdoch and the EchoStar CEO Charlie Ergen, have both addressed the issue publicly during the past week highlighting two issues, who would run it and would it be allowed by regulators?

On the subject of running the service the natural choice would be Charlie Ergen, since he was the founder of EchoStar and the News Corp CEO is in his seventies and runs all of News Corp. But however you look at it Ergen would be reporting to Murdoch and we can’t see that happening, while at the same time we can’t see Murdoch relinquishing any control. Currently DirecTV is run by Chase Carey, who came out of the Fox media empire and has been with Murdoch for almost 20 years.

The FCC rejected the take over of DirecTV by EchoStar four years back and that’s how it ended up in News Corp’s control, even if it only owns 34% of it, bought for $6.6 billion in 2003. That was a very different FCC, operating in a time when there was less competition in TV services.

Right there is another problem for Murdoch. His control would be diluted in a merger with EchoStar to roughly half that shareholding, and Murdoch always insists on absolute control in everything he does.

Sure there are some reasons to do such a deal, bigger content buying power, savings in both satellite capacity and central overheads. But their real problem is one that they have in common, which is that there are attempts to marginalize their satellite TV services using as much interactivity and VoD services as possible from both the cable and the telco community. They can only fight that with some form of broadband network, probably a wireless broadband service (see likely deal with Clearwire elsewhere in this issue).

If DirecTV shares the cost of such a network with EchoStar it doesn’t make them joined at the hip, and they can continue to compete even sharing broadband services. But the truth is that would only save DirecTV about $500 million, and that’s just not enough saving to make it worthwhile to do a merger, it may not even be enough of a saving to make Murdoch happy to help out a competitor.

Charlie Ergen recently told attendees at a media industry get together that a merger could save $3 billion annually in expenses and perhaps this is really about Ergen actively wanting the merger in order to cash out. Probably not, but if he was prepared to stand down and no longer run the merged operation, then Murdoch is far more likely to be interested.