Kazaa owner Sharman Networks, has finally caved in to pressure to get out of the business of illegally allowing its users to swap copyrighted files. It hasn’t made clear any technical details yet, but says it will now use ‘all reasonable means’ to discourage piracy on its network.
But is it at all likely that Kazaa will continue to have a future? Certainly the settlement of $115 million for the record labels and a smaller amount (not revealed) to the US movie studios, gave a glimpse of just how much money Kazaa has netted in advertising revenues over the years. It has by far the biggest brand of any of the P2P networks and sold advertising and spyware inserts to go with its downloads, a business model that was discredited last year when a US Supreme Court made it clear that it would back any copyright infringement case under existing laws.
Last November Grokster and eDonkey moved out of the illegal P2P downloading business, and the author of the BitTorrent software also decided to turn his back on the illegal uses of his software, and began a legal alternative.
Most of these were snapped up by existing legitimate P2P music distribution businesses, and perhaps the same fate lies in store for Kazaa.
Kazaa is free to begin negotiating with content businesses to carry their content legally, but until it articulates its technology for doing so, will still be regarded with suspicion bordering on distaste.
Kazaa has caused the record labels no end of problems and it will be a brave music executive that suggests opening their catalog to Kazaa while under the existing management. A more likely outcome will be that the company changes hands before it can find willing content partners.
Meanwhile, the last remaining, recalcitrant P2P network Limewire, that has yet to take legal threats seriously, is being sued by a group of record labels, including Sony BMG, Warner Bothers and Virgin Records.
The Supreme Court case in 2005 led to a cease and desist order going out to the P2P companies that were not listed in the Grokster Kazaa legal action and most of them immediately capitulated. Limeware has continued to operate an unregulated peer-to-peer network, say the record labels, despite numerous efforts to convince it that it was now clearly illegal.